An open latter to Navistar International: (flame on!)

Discussion in 'International Forum' started by Infosaur, Apr 20, 2012.

  1. Infosaur

    Infosaur Road Train Member

    Gentlemen,

    Due to workload/schedualing issues, my company had to rent an additional 3 DuraStar B-trucks from Penske. They were pretty basicly equipped, rated under 23k and automatics.

    To be honest, if this kind of quality passes for acceptable you all should be, frankly, embarrased.

    Let's start with the most obvious flaw. Your "Automatic" (some sort of electronic clutch unit) provides shifts that would not pass a road test for employment at a company. Honestly if a new candiate for a job at my comany shifted as roughly as that auto-box did we would not hire him. Low speed (stop and go traffic in city driving) is painfull to the point of tourture. If you subjected a member of the Taliban to driving this truck in Manhatan the United Nations would object on the basis of crule and unusual punishment.

    I seriously question the longevity of this clutch unit as Reverse seems to completely baffle it. When you are trying to manuver in tight corners flooring the thottle on the hopes that a gear will engage somewhere north of 1200 rpms is somewhat stressfull. Will Navistar pay for the damages to any parked cars I race into at 10 mph in reverse? It also seems to have a problem with reversing up a grade. If the truck was loaded I can't imagine what kind of throttle input would be required to succesfully contact a dock without ramming into the building.

    On the subject of docking: Most deckplates are only about 6 inches long. So the fact that the truck will roll forward about 8-10 inches after releasing the throttle means I have to push up against the building (gently, so as not to cause any damage) then use the throttle to hold the truck against the dock as I pull the parking brake.

    I know that many drivers these days cannot opperate a clutch, and you have to meet the market, but apparently your engineers are unable to grasp the concept of shifting any better. When rolling down an incline at 2-4 mph (like releasing the brake after a light turns green) can you not calibrate for a 2nd gear start? Slamming in to 1st gear at redline after 50 feet is, frankly, a painfull experience. Conversely, trying to progressively downshift to a stop under load only to freewheel without warning for the bottom 3 gears can add a dangerous length to the stopping distance. If you're trying to kill people why not have the brakes randomly dissconnect instead?

    Oh and one last thing, the warning buzzer on the transmission is stress inducing. I'm trying to make a U-turn in traffic the last thing I need is some pavlovian bell telling me I didn't wait untill the transmission is synched to shift. Try just electricuting the driver instead. (And since I, as the driver feel so mechanicly seperated from the transmission anyway, what with poor gear selection and only the options of DRIVE, HOLD, & 1, why not actually LET the transmission synch itself? The one thing the computer CAN do is determine the speed of input and output and make the shift itself)

    That's just the automatic. Now onto stuff that might just be this unit alone, but still odd.

    The seatbelt, which I understand is required to lock in the event of an accident, is so prone to pre-locking, that it often prevents me from leaning forward to check my mirrors. One instance in particular, after unlaching the belt to remove my wallet to pay for a toll the belt retracted to the b-post and pinned my arm as I was leaving the toll booth. This momentarlly rendered me unable to steer properly in a traffic situation.

    Seriously people. These are voilations us drivers could loose our jobs over!

    Let's recap:

    Damaged freight due to violent shifts.
    Damaged parked cars due to sloppy play in transmission
    Damaged customers dock from ramming
    Seatbelts that we can't put on after a stop.

    That was just from 3 days with your stupid stupd truck, that thought it was smarter than me.

    It's embarrasing.

    FIX IT.

    (PS, I'll spare you my thoughts on the gutless Maxxforce engine, since it's possible the transmission might have been part of the problem)
     
  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. jab8283

    jab8283 Bobtail Member

    38
    16
    Jan 16, 2010
    Indiana, U.S.
    0
    That sounds like an Eaton autoshift transmission. JUNK. Not to worry, an answer will be available in Sept 2012 from Allison Transmission with the brand new TC10-TS fully automatic 10-speed twin countershaft transmission. No more clutch, instead this 10-speed uses a torque convertor. It's basically a 10-speed manual gearbox with torque convertor that shifts so smooth and fast that it'll make your head spin.

    Since Eaton Transmission Corp literally put ZF Meritor Transmission group out of business, we have to wait until Allison releases this brand new transmission. Another transmission worthy of note is made by Caterpillar called the CX-29 and CX-31 which are the same as the Allison model but with only 8-forward gears and 2-reverse gears. It too is smooth as silk however it is not yet available for after market retro-fit or OEM installation except for specific engines. Caterpillar promises to someday allow their 8-speed torque convertor transmission to mate to any engine but have not done so yet. I have not received word from Allison yet but I am assuming the brand new TC10-TS will be used in OEM installation as well as retro-fit to any engine using the same bellhousings that the HD 4000 series automatics used but again, I've not been able to confirm this.

    Eaton Transmission used to be a great company but now their quality sank to basement levels. Eaton forced ZF Meritor out of business because ZF Meritor was building quality products that performed they way they should and as a result their market share soared to the point that Eaton was about to go out of business. So Eaton started a smear campaign to prevent OEM's from installing ZF Meritor transmissions in new trucks and this forced a great transmisison builder out of the truck transmission market and eventually out of business. With ZF Meritor out of business, Volvo group North America started building their own transmissions called "i-shift" which can only be installed in their trucks. This is why Allison transmission decided to build a new tranny because Eaton cannot put Allison out of business they way they did ZF Meritor.

    Once OEM's begin installing Allisons brand new TC10-TS in new truck installs in fall of 2012, the truck owners and drivers will fall in love with them instantly and then slowly start moving away from Eaton transmisions. The only three transmissions that Eaton builds that will survive are the 10, 13 and 18 speed manual gearboxes but I have a feeling their automated transmission divisions will start slowing down as the new Allison transmission will become the new King of the truck transmission market. So be patient as a new tranny is getting ready to hit the market later this year that will permanently knock Eaton Corp out of the automated/automatic truck transmission market because all Eaton builds is JUNK.
     
  4. jab8283

    jab8283 Bobtail Member

    38
    16
    Jan 16, 2010
    Indiana, U.S.
    0
    Oh and BTW - I wouldn't be so hard on the new International Maxx-Force engines. The 11L and 13L Maxx-Force engines are new designs. The brand new Maxx-Force 15L soon to hit the market is a very familiar engine. What I mean by that is the brand new Maxx-Force engines are actually CAT engines with International's fuel system upgrades. It's the same block that CAT has used for many years but remade with IHC's little touches to make the old engine meet EPA requirements.

    As for Maxx-Force engines being weak, I don't believe that to be the case at all. They are different that's for sure because they no longer sound like diesels rather they sound like gasoline engines but with lot's of torque and horsepower and they do not use DEF. So I wouldn't condemn the Maxx-Force engine so quickly but rather the badly operating Eaton automated transmission is causing the engine to operate in derated mode.
     
  5. king Q

    king Q Road Train Member

    2,868
    3,031
    Jul 26, 2010
    Johannesburg sa
    0
    Where is it you are getting your info jab8283?
    ZF are still going strong and separate of Meritor.
    The Volvo I-Shift came straight from Europe where it has been in use for a number of years and is used in Mack as well.
    The Maxforce 13 is based on a MAN motor from Germany not CAT.
     
  6. jab8283

    jab8283 Bobtail Member

    38
    16
    Jan 16, 2010
    Indiana, U.S.
    0
    ZF Meritor company was a joint venture in the U.S. but Eaton Corp put them out of business. The I-Shift tranny in a Mack truck is not surprising since they are the same company. The Maxforce 13 is not the CAT block, that is the Maxforce 15 which is due to release very soon here in the U.S. That is the one engine that all eyes will be on once it is released. I haven't heard any talk as to whether this Maxforce 15 will be available for other class 8 truck chassis such as Kenworth, Peterbilt, or other OEM"s.
     
  7. Dutch

    Dutch Light Load Member

    194
    58
    Nov 21, 2009
    Commiefornia
    0
    The 15 ltr has been released a couple months ago. The maxxforce line is to be offered in navistar products, the cat truck line and other specialty vocation OEM's.
     
  8. Heavyd

    Heavyd Road Train Member

    7,625
    6,027
    Feb 4, 2009
    0
    I just saw my first 2013 Lonestar with Maxxforce 13, that's right, a 13 liter. I gotta say, messy! I'll try to seek out some pictures.
     
  9. Dutch

    Dutch Light Load Member

    194
    58
    Nov 21, 2009
    Commiefornia
    0
    lol ya it is. I saw when they were running field tests with the 15 ltr in the lonestar it looked like a nightmare. Now them in a Paystar is way nicer
     
  10. Brucesmith

    Brucesmith Heavy Load Member

    722
    495
    Jun 16, 2012
    0
    Looks like none of those Maxforce ewngines will be around for long due to not meeting APA compliance. Actaully Navistar is in financial trouble and could either go under or be bought by VW.

    Bruce
     
  11. DrtyDiesel

    DrtyDiesel Road Train Member

    5,348
    2,597
    Feb 14, 2010
    Jacksonville, FL
    0
    I'm actually surprised that my Maxx-force engine has awaken. I swear the more it breaks in the more power comes out of it and also I'm enjoying the engine getting louder, sounds more and more like a Diesel now instead of a gasser.
     
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.