FMCSA board wants to test some truckers for sleep apnea based on BMI
Test some truckers for sleep apnea based on BMI
Page 1 of 5
BMI is a ridiculous way to calculate if some one is too fat.
You can have average height guys that are built husky that will trip the #### thing as obese or at the least over weight when they are in shape.
I hate the darn BMI index.
I'm 5'11" 300+ Took a sleep apnea test at the VA and have no problem. I need to lose weight a lot of weight( I hold it well). When I was in the best shape of my life (marines & wrestling Champ) I weighed 220+lb. and wasn't obese or over weight ALTHOUGH THE BMI SAID I WAS. BMI IS A JOKE.
I am one of those guys that according to bmi are not obese 5'11" 200#, but last summer I did a sleep study and i have sleep apnea pretty bad. now i get to sleep with a mask strapped on my face at night. It actually helped but i still think the bmi scale is bull crap
Sleep apnea is a real problem for me. And according to my BMI it SHOULD be. However being overweight, (or as I like to call it FAT) is not the only thing that causes sleep apnea.
I've used a CPAP for about six years now, including some of the time when I was over the road. It really helped, but recently I've noticed those exhaustion symptoms rearing their ugly head again.
It is a clear and present danger for anyone who drives. I'm going to have to get tested again before I will even consider getting back into trucking.
Got turned down at PRIME because they require a 38.5 BMI or less. I am a 40.6 right now, never been tested for sleep apnea but I'm not tired when I wake up either. My father suffered from it but he was 450+ most of his life. Recruiter told me if I drop 15-20 pounds I can get back on as long as they are still hiring new grads.
I weigh 290 and I am 5'11. Back in Dec 2005 I stated to lose weight after a loved one died. I was 396.lbs and By November 2006 I was 225.lbs. I could run one mile in 8:10 and two in 16:30 I never ran more than two because my right lung would hurt after the 1st mile.
I kept the weight off until December 2007. My house burned in Sept 07 (I inherited it in Sept 05 when my grandfather passed), my dad died dec 07, my mom died mar 08, had baby boy born june 08 (my 1st child therefore my parents never got to see a grandchild), Nov 08 my gradmother died. To top it off my insurance screwed me around until jul 08 on paying me for my house fire (they tried everything they could to get out of paying and had to pay by court order).
While all that wonderful luck was occurring I went from 225.lbs to 299. Since March 31st 09 I have went down from 299 to 291. I told the Prime recruiter I would be at the 275 or lower by the end of April.
Even though I gained 70 pounds I can run 1 mile in 9 minutes. I am riding a moutain bike 16 miles everyday plus walking 4 miles in less than an hour.
BMI is total ########. Take my case, I was a 41.7 BMI on March 31st 2009, Starting that day I ran 1 mile in 9 minutes, walked the other 3.
April 1st I rode my bike 16 miles in 1 1/2 hours, walked 4 miles.
April 2nd I rode my bike 16 miles in 1 1/2 hours, walked 4 miles.
April 3rd I ran 1 mile and walked 3.
Today I will I ride my bike 16 miles in 1 1/2 hours, walk 4 miles.
But according to BMI I am obese. I know people the are in the 20's on the BMI scale that couldn't keep pace with my 290 pound fat ###.I think BMI should be either dropped of complimented with a scoring system that is based on exercises.
Sleep apnea testing is being pushed by doctors and medical equipment suppliers that will profit from it. Maybe some of our politicians should be tested for sleep apnea so they can state awake when congress is in session . Some pretty high BMI numbers there .
I'm sure you are right about that Rick. But I can tell you from first hand experience, that if you really do need it, it is a God send!
OTOH, they have all of these add ons now, that I really have to wonder about. As an example, I've got a buddy who just got one. Per his doctor, his has oxygen added with it.
Now my question is, if he needs oxygen at night, then why the heck doesn't he need it in the day time when he is (very) active! There probably is a reason for this, I just don't quite get it.
Last edited by a moderator: Apr 5, 2009
Page 1 of 5