@rollin coal - once again you made me pause to think again (thanks for that) but....after some deliberation I conclude it is the same physics. The tube is affixed to a tire (part of the rim) and it balances them just like beads inside the tire. For sure, they both are using the same concept.
The only valid argument against the centramatics can be made about the insufficient amount of shot ( BTW thanks for using the term - but is it not smaller beads still?) inside the tube but I can only imagine that the imbalance would have to be colossal for the rings to fail which in that case adding more shot along with enlarging the diameter could adjust it by the manufacturer, if there were any negative reports . Correct me If am wrong but I thought that drive rings were bigger than the ones used on steers. I have to admit that I don't have any lab data and I never used beads inside tires to argue or defend cetramatics effectiveness vs beads but I'd have to be demonstrated that they are any worse to stop believing in them. All I know is that my tires look round and are evenly worn like they're drawn by a compass. Most importantly, I've never had a dilemma of whether or not I should replace steer tires due to their age and not their being bumpy.
How long before replacing steering tires?
Discussion in 'Ask An Owner Operator' started by TallJoe, Dec 7, 2018.
Page 4 of 5
-
-
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
-
The rings are not where they need to be to balance the tire. They are ineffective. The media needs to be able to go to the exact opposite side of the imbalance in the width of that tire whever it may be to balance things out. If the media is all inside of the tire it will do that. If it's in a ring sandwiched in between your drive tires it can't, it's not even possible. And there isn't enough of it in there anyway. Run whatever makes you happy. I know what has worked and what hasn't with my ride.
Lepton1 Thanks this. -
I have a little short of 200,000 miles on my steer tires with the Centramatics and about 100,000 miles on my drives with Centramatics. I have really even wear on all my tractor tires. That's a miracle. Before Centramatics I had issues with cupping and feathering on all my tires. My first set of drives lasted a whopping 80,000 miles after a three axle alignment and my drives...fuggedaboudit.
I AM intrigued by your description of putting balancing balls INSIDE the tires. That makes sense to me. What kind and how many (or what weight) do you put in each tire?
For now I'm really really happy with the choice to put Centramatics on all three axles. My tires wear evenly and I expect to get over 200,000 miles from all positions. Tires were a fairly large cost center for me, now I am hoping that will reign in to normal.
One other thing about Centramatics on duals, I no longer have to hunt for the inside tire valve stem to check pressure. There's only one opening and it's easy to find.TallJoe Thanks this. -
OK I'll look into it... If the Centramatics is a snake oil, let's expose it but I hope it is not.
Edit to add,
Centramatics are too popular to let people continue to believe in their effectiveness, if there is not any. This forum is a good platform for that. I hate to think if what you stated is warranted and true because I myself recomended the purchase of those to a person or two, which they did. So I'll feel stupid if I have to confess to them that I convinced (I can't stomach to say "fooled") them into the purchase of something scammy that they are happy about so far too.Last edited: Dec 9, 2018
-
Dave_in_AZ, TallJoe and Lepton1 Thank this.
-
-
Somebody show proof. I don't want to hear- well I got this and that.
I want to see physical proof that they actually make the rubber magically make the rubber stay on the casing.
They are designed to balance the tire supposedly. So either they tire is either runs completely bald in 1 spot and has tread on the other side. OR it is magically applying rubber going down the road. Which is it?
Now if your telling me that you are able to run it down to 1 or 2/32 instead of taking it off at 6 or 7/32 because it looks more round to you, that's not the same. -
The way I see it work is that the Tire + rim (or two rims and two tires "duals") + lugs + pebbles stuck in the tread + centramatic tube ring attached to the rim sum up to one rotating mass which can be balanced by the loose little beads inside the tube - instead of beads or even golf balls inside the very tire - the method once used too. It is about balancing the whole rotating assembly, not only the tire.
This brings me back to the intriguing dilemma from a few posts before...let's agree that lugs and and part of the rim extend outside the tire width and can contribute to imbalance too, so by what Rollin Coal said then the media inside the tire would not be able to balance those either but they are balanced even by weights glued to the rim.
The only way I see it as not working properly would be when there is not enough loose little beads inside the tube. Is there sufficient amount of those to create sufficient centrifugal force to correct imbalance, would be my question.
The best method to prove it or disprove it would be to attach the centramatic ring along with the tire on a rim on a balancing machine...at Love's tire shop for example.Last edited: Dec 10, 2018
-
When it's time to put new tires on I use a shop vac to recover the old beads and weigh them out on a set of scales and use them again in the new tires. A few years ago I had a set of recaps with beads in them that were some smooth running tires.
Centramatic has 16 ounces inside that ring doesn't it? So that's 8 ounces of weight per tire and it isn't even where it's really needed. The centripetal force can't really send it where it needs to go on a set of duals because it is trapped inside a small ring in between the wheels. Beads inside of a tire are much more effective at dynamically keeping your tires balanced.Last edited: Dec 12, 2018
daf105paccar Thanks this. -
Dave_in_AZ and Lepton1 Thank this.
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
Page 4 of 5