Deciding between CDL job offers

Interesting, I'm a Class B holder and this would be my first hazmat gig between these two still feel low?

 

Based out of dayton. Amerigas is in monroe (roughly 32-33min from me, local is maybe 18-20 mins)

 

At some point I may want to move to Arizona depending how the market looks out there but as of now I'd like to get the experience

 

Pay sucked. No idea how the benefits were because I didn't elect them at the time but I'm sure decent at least. Pension was okay, the work was underpaid really doing construction work for 20.71 and snow plowing wasn't worth it when you can be held liable depending on the situation wasn't worth my CDL. But outlook may have been different at a different garage which I couldn't transfer to until a year up.. some race situations when you're the only black guy on 2 shifts you can feel the uneasy vibes and some of what was said I can go on and on