Cummins vs. Cat
Discussion in 'Trucks [ Eighteen Wheelers ]' started by gtn428, Oct 26, 2008.
Page 23 of 24
-
-
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
-
DrtyDiesel said: ↑little cat 500 said: ↑Personally one reason I like cat is because I've been told that with straight pipes, the higher the horsepower, the louder it gets.......
I do like the cummins ISX I heard with straights......Click to expand...Click to expand... -
Freightlinerbob said: ↑DrtyDiesel said: ↑What was that you were saying about NOT wanting to be Billy Big Rigger?Click to expand...
Sound
Free flowing exhaust
Looks
I'm not out to be some bad@ss, I just want a truck I like, nothing billy big rigger about having nice thingsClick to expand... -
DrtyDiesel said: ↑Freightlinerbob said: ↑Just because I want straights on my truck doesn't mean I'm billy big rigger. I'd want straights for three reasons
Sound
Free flowing exhaust
Looks
I'm not out to be some bad@ss, I just want a truck I like, nothing billy big rigger about having nice thingsClick to expand...
But arguing for a particular motor based on sound and looks is. IMO of course. That's why I find it so freaking hilarious when some yellow motor people have to come to grips with the fact that their engine of choice is no longer available. As I said in my first post.Click to expand... -
Freightlinerbob said: ↑DrtyDiesel said: ↑You're absolutely right about nothing wrong about having/ wanting nice things.
But arguing for a particular motor based on sound and looks is. IMO of course. That's why I find it so freaking hilarious when some yellow motor people have to come to grips with the fact that their engine of choice is no longer available. As I said in my first post.Click to expand...
I just traded trucks today, my 379exhd with a c15 for this new kw t660 with a cummins ISX. I'm interested in seeing how this thing moves. My buddy with the same truck at this company was pulling a hill, loaded with the same stuff I had, but was 10,000lbs heavier than me and was leaving me in the dust.Click to expand... -
Forget all the PDF,DEF,SCR go with a Glider Kit and a 07 c-15 or even better c-16 Cat.....
-
RKH said: ↑Forget all the PDF,DEF,SCR go with a Glider Kit and a 07 c-15 or even better c-16 Cat.....Click to expand...
-
I have a 3406E Cat, Cummins N14 and ISX and Detroit 12.7.
Hands down the N14 has been the best of the bunch.
I love Cat. They built the world but I call them like I see them. That Cummins just keeps on running.
My N14 does not use a drop of oil either. I've never personally seen a diesel engine in a truck that didn't use a drop of oil from oil change to oil change but my N14 does it.
The ISX is the most Powerful of the bunch and the 3406E is next with the N14 and then the Detroit.
The Best Jake Brake by a mile is on the ISX and the N14 and Cat are good too but nothing like the ISX.
The only problem that I've had with the ISX is the EGR Cooler and Turbo. Fix those and it is one bad hot rod. My ISX is pre-DPF too. -
I beg to differ..
having driven a bunch of N-14s, I have to yelp them out on their "injector intervals" per say... I've gone through about a thousand injectors in a bunch of N-14s I've driven in the past 11 years and never a single injector on a CAT!
I drove a detroit 12.7L 350HP 4.70 rears and 9spd tranny, for a good 8 months (I'd dare mention this since it was a big impact in my driving career) this thing would run 75 MPH flat at 21 RPMS! that's right, 2100 revolutions per minute and never broke. I asked the onwer for a bigger engine (him being a mechanic) but his reply at the frequently asked question was, if it breaks I'll put another one in it, just like it.
I drove a bunch of all of these engines, I love the 3406E CAT.. with a blow by of 4 inches and still pulling I-70 west on the rockies at 30 mph at 78k lbs gross with an 18 spd in a 1997 W900L.. it was a rush to drive that truck, loved it more than any other, even my beloved current truck now.
I drove 2 N-14s in the same 2 month back to back about 2 years ago for 2 months, (the driver to one of them quit and went home across the border). one was a century with a 10 spd and 3.58 rears, the other a volvo with a 10 spd and 3.58 gears. the century gave me 6.5 mpg while the volvo only did 5.8. same loads, same routes same trailers (as I switched since I liked the continental tires on it) having said all these the conclusion is always the same..
what do you prefer? SONY or Samsung? sprite or coke? CRST or CR ENGLAND? do your homework, believe in what you do. if any of these engines really sucked the would be no longer available, ask Mercedes. you say CATs 2007 and up suck, I said you should seat and have a talk with Mr Haney.
DD15s are bad mofos, I drove one for 5 months when they first came out and I was impressed. bunch of harness problems, harness was replaced 3 times during those 5 months.
ISX bunch of EGR problems, good fuel mileage when calibrated right. not enough pull power for me (1 of the trucks I drove with an ISX was a WINCH TRUCK)
volvos suck.. don't want to get into the all and all, but I just state my opinion on them. break down and you count your blessings you're near a volvo dealer that can REALLY work on your VOLVO!
CATs 2007 and up NO EGR ! -
I'm not out to be some bad@ss, I just want a truck I like, nothing billy big rigger about having nice things[/QUOTE]
Well then detriot wins hands down much louder then cats!
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
Page 23 of 24
Related Categories
-
Abs stuck on
TFord posted May 9, 2025 at 4:15 PM -
Old Fruehauf dump
JbugBDT posted May 8, 2025 at 5:22 PM -
Carbon Monoxide
Tb0n3 posted May 8, 2025 at 4:16 PM -
M2 cruise control/brake...
MtnWestRenewables posted May 8, 2025 at 3:40 PM -
3406E Sputtering Only Under...
Jordonh posted May 8, 2025 at 2:04 PM -
8v92 Flywheel
TheMissingFlywheel2876 posted May 8, 2025 at 4:42 AM -
Strange compressor issue
Rideandrepair posted May 7, 2025 at 5:35 PM -
Cummins isx15 crankcase...
mitmaks posted May 7, 2025 at 12:57 AM -
SPN-520349 FMI-14
Nuts & Bolts posted May 7, 2025 at 12:30 AM -
01 379 N14 celect+
Alan50 posted May 6, 2025 at 11:33 PM
Loading...
Recent Threads
-
I-40 TN to NC
JC1971 posted May 9, 2025 at 8:15 PM -
US Xpress woes and moving on to...
jaws2003 posted May 9, 2025 at 6:18 PM -
Driver Playing Through
mjd4277 posted May 9, 2025 at 5:28 PM -
Abs stuck on
TFord posted May 9, 2025 at 4:15 PM -
Sludge in the blowby
DT Trucker posted May 9, 2025 at 6:58 AM -
Truck hits railroad overpass
Chinatown posted May 9, 2025 at 12:46 AM -
ATA applauds suspension of...
Diesel Dave posted May 8, 2025 at 9:16 PM -
If I got a violation for fire...
Jemseliacin5 posted May 8, 2025 at 8:25 PM -
Old Fruehauf dump
JbugBDT posted May 8, 2025 at 5:22 PM -
Carbon Monoxide
Tb0n3 posted May 8, 2025 at 4:16 PM
Loading...