What are your thoughts on automatic vs manual transmissions?

Discussion in 'Questions From New Drivers' started by Jbrow327, Dec 24, 2021.

  1. Jbrow327

    Jbrow327 Light Load Member

    Joined:
    Sep 28, 2019
    Messages:
    141
    Thanks Received:
    83
    0
    On this forum, I get the vibe that manual transmissions are for super truckers and automatics are sissies who can't handle the power. Lol!
    They will say that having a manual gives you more control over the truck, but you can put automatics into manual mode to control your gearing.
    They will say that having a manual has one less computer to break on your truck, but unless you're driving a very old truck, most things on your engine are controlled by computers.
    What do you guys thinks?
     
    Kyle G. Thanks this.
  2. Grumppy

    Grumppy Trucker Forum STAFF Staff Member

    Joined:
    Dec 11, 2010
    Messages:
    3,085
    Thanks Received:
    10,562
    Location:
    West Monroe, La
    0
    Automatics have some good points but......... Overall, If I truly had my choice, I'd take a manual without hesitation
     
    Last edited: Dec 24, 2021
    Hulld, Opus, NorthEastTrucker and 10 others Thank this.
  3. Rubber duck kw

    Rubber duck kw Road Train Member

    Joined:
    Dec 9, 2017
    Messages:
    6,092
    Thanks Received:
    17,686
    0
    You want to push the pedal and go and not have to think just a little bit get an auto. You want a transmission you don't have to worry about a sensor or some #### shutting you down for who knows how long, a transmission you can almost always limp home to a mechanic you know knows what they're doing to fix it get a manual.
     
  4. Gliding ProStar

    Gliding ProStar Heavy Load Member

    Joined:
    Nov 12, 2016
    Messages:
    860
    Thanks Received:
    6,132
    Location:
    Waxahachie, Texas
    0
    I agree with what the other posters have said. I say choose the transmission and spec your truck to best suit the needs of your operation.

    Tell us what your specific plans are or your current operation and that will help the forum understand your needs.
     
  5. ZVar

    ZVar Road Train Member

    Joined:
    Sep 10, 2010
    Messages:
    10,911
    Thanks Received:
    23,827
    Location:
    Flint, MI
    0
    I look around work and see all the 20 year drivers getting a left knee replacement and I have no problem with an auto. Now if we ever got the trucks on the expressway that might be different. The shuttle run I'm currently doing that is 100% side roads and start-stop traffic a day I'm glad for the automatic.
    OTR I'd likely prefer a manual still, if for no other reason more control at the low end like when backing.
     
  6. Rubber duck kw

    Rubber duck kw Road Train Member

    Joined:
    Dec 9, 2017
    Messages:
    6,092
    Thanks Received:
    17,686
    0
    I first read that as 20 year olds getting knee replacements and was wondering what torture facility you were working in. Local delivery type work I can see an auto being kind of nice, still wouldn't personally like them.
     
  7. jason6541

    jason6541 Road Train Member

    Joined:
    Mar 5, 2012
    Messages:
    2,425
    Thanks Received:
    5,366
    Location:
    Omaha, NE
    0
    Well you can’t pull start an automated transmission, you can’t rock an automated transmission, you can’t tow one a short distance. Replace the clutch in one is about 3 times the cost. Clutch won’t normally last 500k and my manual clutch will last almost a million miles
     
    Last edited: Dec 24, 2021
  8. MacLean

    MacLean Road Train Member

    Joined:
    Sep 12, 2017
    Messages:
    1,299
    Thanks Received:
    3,852
    0
    I’d change my manual to an automated in a heartbeat if it was feasible. I don’t need any status or a 6’ high shifter for guys to see as I come into the Truck Stop. And on top of it all my left knee is killing me. I dread seeing stop & go traffic.
     
  9. Chinatown

    Chinatown Road Train Member

    Joined:
    Aug 28, 2011
    Messages:
    74,742
    Thanks Received:
    170,094
    Location:
    Henderson, NV & Orient
    0
    I vote for automatics. Ran 48 states and Canada pulling hazmat tankers and loved that automatic transmission.
     
  10. Val_Caldera

    Val_Caldera Road Train Member

    Joined:
    Apr 2, 2021
    Messages:
    2,569
    Thanks Received:
    7,935
    Location:
    TARHEEL
    0
    I Preferred Manual because there's NO LAG unlike "auto" shift.

    Companies appear to be going to this: (to slightly borrow from Henry Ford):
    "You Can Have Any Transmission You Want As Long As It's An Automatic".

    Manuals Will Continue until completely non available, then Only Driven By OUTLAWS!
    While "in theory" one has some control in "Manual Mode" such is VERY LIMITED because the "system" disallows High Revs therefore it's still, as claimed, a Nanny Operation. Automatics are almost useless in Inclement Weather Because The Driver is UNABLE to secure a Higher Or Lower Gear, at least in the many Auto Shift Trucks I've Driven both OTR and Local from Years 2010 to 2019, AND when backing, there was ZERO feathering (models varied), just SLAM, BAM, BOOM at Docks, so "safety improvement" appeared eliminated!
    Manual Controlled By Driver.

    "They say" a lot don't They?!

    Older Trucks had of course less computerization or zero back a bit further therein allowing actual Driving Characteristics to be developed/maintained.
    In 1998 I trained at a Driver "School" in Goodlettsville, TN., and their Trucks were Manual. After "Schooling" and some Years later, I preferred a Reverse 9 (Pete) as well 13 Speed (Freightshaker). (13 speed auto was so yay)

    I think You Should Drive What Makes You Comfortable!
    I'm in no way suggesting one is better than the other.
    Manual was the Leader, Still Is, yet sadly THE TRUE ERA OF TRUCKING started collapsing before I started in '98 yet MANY of the Best Hands were still Driving and some Remain.
    You Can Become One Of The Best!!

    Thanks For Your Questions!
    CHEERS!!

    P.S.: Last Auto Shift I drove OTR for a few Years had a Clutch Pedal. Was FUN in Atlanta, Choo-Choo, Crashville, Little Rock, Texarkana and on DFW Loop.
    Straight trucks did not.
     
    Last edited: Dec 24, 2021
    Reason for edit: spelling, grammar, other.