Aluminum vs. composite flatbeds

Discussion in 'Ask An Owner Operator' started by shooter19802003, Feb 24, 2010.

  1. shooter19802003

    shooter19802003 Road Train Member

    5,654
    42,113
    Feb 8, 2010
    Idaho
    0
    I have decided to buy a flatbed. I have always had transcraft composite flatbeds. I am thinking about an all aluminum flat though. Any down side to aluminum? If I buy used what should I look for in a aluminum flat. Any stress points to look for? Any brand to watch out for? Any luck with a good brand/trailer? I haven't been around aluminum flats that much so I really don't know what to look for.

    Thanks
     
    359kool Thanks this.
  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. Jfaulk99

    Jfaulk99 Road Train Member

    2,914
    1,652
    May 16, 2009
    Couch
    0
    What do you mostly haul?
     
  4. Billy_Big_Rigger

    Billy_Big_Rigger Bobtail Member

    19
    4
    Jan 13, 2010
    NW Indiana
    0
    You can’t beat a Reitnouer big bubba they are bullet proof, and hold value. I know mac makes a great trailer also. One of these two trailers will out last any transcraft. I can legally scale 50,000 on the deck with my kenworth and big bubba full of fuel.
     
  5. rbht

    rbht Heavy Load Member

    888
    525
    Jan 23, 2010
    CT,NH
    0
    Look out around where the axels bolt to the frame and around the 5th wheel plate, personaly i have a 00 Ravens and its bin a great trailer i put 54,000 lbs on the deck and the arch is still like new if you haul alot of coils make sure the trailer is set up for it i wheigh 30,500 full of fuel with my 379exhd with 2 sets of tarps, log stakes and all other equiment.
     
    Last edited: Feb 24, 2010
  6. shooter19802003

    shooter19802003 Road Train Member

    5,654
    42,113
    Feb 8, 2010
    Idaho
    0
    I haul equipment now. I have an 11 axle. I think that I am going to get out of the heavy haul industry and get back into flat bed. Less hastle and BS involved. The company that I am going to lease to says I need to be able to scale 48k. I am looking at an 2003 western start 4964 ex 76" starlight with a 6nz and a 13 speed. The truck is kinda on the heavy side so I am thinking I have to go with a Aluminum flat to make the weight.
    The company I am looking to goto hauls alot of building products, wood, and coils. I was also thinking about a covered wagon kit.

    Here are some trailers that I found at the same dealership. Are these prices decent? I am not looking for anything real fancy, just a good looking and structrualy sound trailer.

    All of the below trailers are all aluminum and 48' 102" spread axle and all have sliding winches and 2 boxes between the spread.

    2008 Reitnouer Big Bubba for $36,900.00
    2008 REITNOUER MAXLITE for $35,500.00
    2006 reitnouer maximiser for $23,000.00
    1999 Benson for $9,900.00
    They also have a few brand new 2009 Reitnouer 25 th Maxmiser
    that are frickin beautiful! They say call for a price. I am going with the old standby....if you gotta ask......you can't afford it! :biggrin_2556:


    EDIT: Here is the Reitnouer web site stats page. I think that I might get the maximiser. http://www.reitnouer-trailers.com/flatbed.htm

    EDIT...again: The only thing it doesn't tell you on that site (unless I am blind and stupid...never know) is how much the trailer weighs.
     
    Last edited: Feb 24, 2010
  7. Billy_Big_Rigger

    Billy_Big_Rigger Bobtail Member

    19
    4
    Jan 13, 2010
    NW Indiana
    0
    Don't do the maxlite it doesn't have a coil package its only rated for 45,000 in 10 ft The maximiser is rated for 50,000 in 10 ft, the big bubba is rated for 60,000 in 10ft. The bigger bubba is rated for 74,000 in 10 ft.
    I'm not sure on the pricing. I just bought a brand new 2010 reitnouer dropmiser 52ft 6inch for 39,900. Call reitnouer they were advertising 2005 big bubbas for $16,000 48ft102's. Old prime trailers if they still have them, you have to pick them up in Springfield mo. Good deal.

    They are light trailers. My step deck weighs 10,200 pounds and it's a 52ft 6inch spread.
    Not sure on the big bubbas never weighed them by themselves, but I can do 50,000 on the deck legal full of fuel, and I carry 5 tarps, a spare tire, tons of equipment, 6x6 lumber coil racks(use to haul big single coils 50-72,000 pounders).
     
    Last edited: Feb 24, 2010
  8. shooter19802003

    shooter19802003 Road Train Member

    5,654
    42,113
    Feb 8, 2010
    Idaho
    0

    Right on, thanks for the help. I will e-mail them about the trailers.


    EDIT: do you have a link for them?
     
  9. TURKER

    TURKER Medium Load Member

    344
    97
    Aug 11, 2009
    Raleigh NC
    0
    Hey I just bought a Benson 2000 year for $10250 and I had 47000+ lb and arch is still good and it weighs 8900 lb .has coil package they are great trailers.I like East and Mac but cant afford them. 1999 Benson will serve you best and wont hurt your bank account.my2cents good luck
     
  10. shooter19802003

    shooter19802003 Road Train Member

    5,654
    42,113
    Feb 8, 2010
    Idaho
    0

    Thanks for the help. Here are the specs on the benson. From their site.

    The Model 524 is the standard duty trailer that is anything but standard. With weights as low as 7,990# for a 48'X102" and 52,000# concentrated loading in 4' this is the perfect trailer to maximize payload on those 80,000# non-permitted loads.

    I think that will haul all I want....providing that it still has a good arch in it. Like I said. I'm not really looking for fancy. I want to make money first....then add the fancy. :biggrin_25525:
     
  11. Jfaulk99

    Jfaulk99 Road Train Member

    2,914
    1,652
    May 16, 2009
    Couch
    0
    Mac is by far the strongest. The 80k model is rated for 80,000 in 4ft with 2 axles, 100,000 in 4' for 6 or more axles, The closest competitor is the Bigger Bubba, MMX East, 724 Benson all at 72k in 4'. Reitnouer is probably my 2nd choice. I've got 2 East's, one Beast and one MMX, 3 Wilsons (2 combo one all aluminum) Had a Benson, it was as strong as a wet noodle. That and Transcraft now owns them so I'm sure the quality went farther in the crapper.

    If your wanting a sidekit or a conestoga don't get a weak trailer. The East Beast I have is a POS for hauling coils. The trailer is so weak you can barely get the side boards out loaded because the trailer sags. It's a 4 axle so that's the only thing that saves it, you have to drop one extra axle in order to put the side kit back together.:biggrin_25513: Same with a conestoga. I've seen transcrafts with only a 45k coil flatten out so much the conestoga is loose, which just kills the tarp from the wind. A friend had a Transcraft with a Conestoga and even with lumber the tarp was loose. There are so many repo trailers around you can find a great deal. Just watch out for some guys on truckpaper, they are asking more for used stuff than a new one costs. Also IMO Intraxx 300 suspension is a must. There is barely any weight difference between the 250 (25k) and the 300 (30k) but the ride is much better.

    I wouldn't buy a combo flat. I've got several now and have sold several. New there is only about $5k difference in price but not having any rust is worth the extra money. There isn't a whole lot of weight savings between the 2 but aluminum trailers are rated for a higher capacity. Most will tell you that you don't need the weight capacity. But as I'm sure you know with your 11 axle you've never thought to yourself "man I wish that trailer was a little weaker"

    Before I paid $26 for an '06 Maximizer I'd buy this 2008 Mac.
    This isn't the 80k but still a strong trailer. 2008 for $20k I believe this is the 60k (60k-4' but they did make a 70k for a while)
     
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.