I am looking for a doser for my t680 which has wildly different prices. Cummins is about $650 but an aftermarket like Bosch is around $200. In the case of a part like a doser, why would an OEM be so much better quality to be priced at 3x an aftermarket? Same goes for machined parts that are essentially the same dimensions as the OEM. Don't large aftermarket brands have similar quality controls to catch parts that dont come out to specifications? Is it the metal blends? Combination of a lot of things?
OEM vs Aftermarket reliability, what's the difference?
Discussion in 'Ask An Owner Operator' started by RunningAces, Jan 6, 2026.
-
-
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
-
From what I've noticed Paccar loves to mark up their parts. You can roll the dice on the $200 doser, see what happens.
-
Who do you think makes the parts for Cummins?
Toomanybikes Thanks this. -
It is questionable if Bosch even makes that part. The amount of relabeled Chinese crap is out of control.
Last edited: Jan 6, 2026
Diesel Dave and 1999 C12 Thank this. -
I myself pay OEM prices. Especially with any emissions parts. Others will differ. I at least know I have a peace of mind that I won’t be gambling on aftermarket parts.
JB7, wichris and Carpenter Scotty Thank this. -
I always bought OEM sensors when it came to emission stuff mostly because my truck went to the local Peterbilt shop for work and most of the time the computer has to be told that the sensor was replaced.
If I had the software myself I would entertain an aftermarket sensor if it came from a known seller and the price was right. No way I’d chance a knockoff from Amazon or eBay.AModelCat and Diesel Dave Thank this. -
I have not had the greatest luck in general with aftermarket parts. I go straight to the dealer most cases now. At least it's not a huge PITA to try and get a replacement part if it's bad out of the box.
blairandgretchen, 1999 C12, JB7 and 1 other person Thank this. -
Oem has always been more expensive then aftermarket.
Aftermarket. For some parts. Are refurbished.
Last century aftermarket was okay to use. These days. You're just wasting your money.
A perfect example is cars. No one wants to spend money on oem cats and o2 sensors. They buy aftermarket and the engine light never goes off. That money you saved was a complete waste of money.Diesel Dave and 1999 C12 Thank this.
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.