Do you run illegal on your logs?

Discussion in 'Trucking Industry Regulations' started by LogsRus, Mar 28, 2007.

Do you log a 10 hour break but only stop for 8 hours or close to it?

  1. *

    Yes I stop for my full 10, I don't want handcuffs on me

    60.6%
  2. *

    I only stop for 8 but I log a 10 hour break

    8.5%
  3. *

    I stop for less than 7 hours most of the time

    6.4%
  4. *

    I do whatever I feel my body can handle @ the time

    27.1%
  1. dancnoone

    dancnoone "Village Idiot"

    9,922
    3,713
    May 6, 2007
    Mississippi
    0
    Then you should be down in the "pit" explaining to your company why a driver should not be given an appointment for a load he picked up at 6pm (after emptying out at 6am, after sleeping at the receiver all night) and asked to have it 500 miles down the road in 10 hours. This driver has been up for 12 hours already waiting for his load assignment...But your company, says (yes they do!) he has been on break all day, and is ready to roll.

    I love safety departments. Especially those that can tell me my legal and moral obligations.

    Companies also should adhere to legal and moral obligations. The moral obligation I speak of, is that one that insures ALL employees will make a good wage, while maintaining a legal log book. Instead of "operations" keeping a log of "out of sevice/hours" on drivers, later to be used to terminate said drivers, at the next "incident". Or they simply give them **** loads for the duration of their employment, trying to starve them into submission.

    Bottom Line: When OTR companies are forced to pay hourly wages. You will see near 100% compliance with logging and speed limits. And, that will never happen! Because, they are not legally or morally bound to pay OTR drivers for their time.

    If I punched a clock when I pulled into the terminal to get my truck, then again when I returned. And was paid for every hour I was out (in the past) My average wage would have been less than $7.00 per hour, with no overtime pay.

    You want compliance...argue for hourly pay for your drivers.
     
  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. buck and a half

    buck and a half Mr. Miles & Miles with Many Smiles

    775
    57
    Aug 11, 2006
    madison,me
    0
    In my life of trucking I have done it all,legally and illegally,I used to love being an outlaw. Today,drivers,believe me,it is not worth the chance you take. If a kid runs out into the road,somebodys pet dog,a grandma out for a ride and hits you,you may as well kiss your license goodbye,pack your clothes away,give your wife or girlfriend and your loved kids a hug and kiss,cause you are probably gonna spend some time in jail,maybe even 5 years.Your name gets rubbed in the mud for the rest of your life at home and where it happened at.By the time the civil suit is done,your family could lose their home cars etc,and your the one that caused it. If you are over on your 14,70 or 11,stop and think,it is not worth that chance,just a message from my experiences and many many miles and readings of drivers being jailed for manslaughter,even if a drunk hits you,you are at fault,because you should have been off the road yourself.I used to be crazy but now I'm sane. I have never ever hurt anybody yet,thank god.
     
  4. Pyro

    Pyro Bobtail Member

    28
    13
    May 4, 2007
    0
    I always make my logs look good and legal, but there are many times that what really happens in a day is totally differant than what my logs say. One thing I found that works well is keeping your log current all day and then at the end of the day redoing it to say what you want or need to match what you want to be able to do the next day. The way I do it is by always keeping all the same stops but shortening the times I spend at places, especially getting loaded and unloaded. I saw in here someone saying about fuel stops, that is one thing I do keep logged right on time no matter what I might do with the rest of the day
     
  5. LogsRus

    LogsRus Log it Legal

    2,589
    358
    Nov 23, 2006
    Indianapolis, Indiana
    0
    If you generally take a 7 hour break why not make it 8 and be legal? All you need to do now is stop for 2 hours during the day for either eatiing, sleep, relax and boom stop for 8 at the end of your 14 hour and wala you are split breaking and need to understand it is not that simple as I stated. You need to learn it though. You can log legal and be happy all in the same!

    Many drivers are not getting the fact if you learn how to split break you can log legal and be happy all in the same. Split breaking is safer at that. It kind of forces you to take a break during your 14 hour period. Instead of driving 11 & taking a 7 hour break and driving another 11?? Go figure! One day I will get everyone to understand this and wallaa they will change the rules completely!

    Split breaking is VERY VERY VERY EASY! IT'S AS EASY AS "A,B,C". It just takes a minute to pick up on it.
     
  6. 25(2)+2

    25(2)+2 Trucker Forum STAFF Staff Member

    18,750
    45,476
    Sep 18, 2006
    the road less travelled
    0
    Split breaking used to be easier and more effective, It's not that easy anymore unless you do the 2 or more plus 8 or more, in which case you break for more than 10 hours in 2 breaks. Nobody likes being forced to run when they are tired, but the present rule forces that because you need to break for at least 8 hours to extend your working time(driving time). Canada has a better set-up now because that meaningless 2 hour break can be used in increments covering showering, eating, napping, or shopping. It doesn't have to be continuous. All of your protesting to the contrary doesn't change the fact that the present system is lousy for anyone, who, for whatever reason, can't sleep for about 8 hours at a time or can't drive for 11 hours at a time. Do some research on sleep and driving, don't just take the DOT's word on this.
     
  7. LogsRus

    LogsRus Log it Legal

    2,589
    358
    Nov 23, 2006
    Indianapolis, Indiana
    0
    I will debate this because you are forgetting the fact the driver above stated "he sleeps for 7 hours" he is logging a 10 hour break but taking a 7.
    If he only stayed for 8 hours and stopped during his 14 hour period for a couple hours he would be split breaking. In return after his 8 hour break (or 2nd break) he would only have say 6 hours to drive and take a 2 hour break, then he is on the road again. He stops every so many hours and is on the road again. He never shuts the truck down for a full 10.

    I understand the Canada rule is much easier on the 10 hour break. They just require a 10 hour break. Their 10 hour break is almost like our split break.

    Yes I like Canada's HOS rules, but the problem is we are not Canada drivers (most of us, those who are I will talk to you about your rules but I am rusty/new at that) so we must concentrate on what the USA drivers have to work with.

    Again if a driver isn't going to shut down for a full 10 hours and sleeps 6 hours and is ready to go, can't you negotiate 2 more hours? if the answer is yes; split break then!

    Many of you are not getting the point on how it works. If you study the sheets and if you give me your e-mail and study the sheet that I can't post it might help.
    I had a driver last night who: takes a 10 hour break, drives 30 minutes. Feels tired (why? I don't know) anyhow takes off 7 hours, then goes to driving. He doesn't have time now to finish the load, but if he would have taken 8 hours he could have split breaked and possibly finished that load on time. But he was the one in class saying split breaking is to hard or it is stupid. Well in this case it would have been very helpfull to know your options for certain situations.

    I remember the old way drivers would say it is not worth it and to hard. IT's all because you don't want to learn how to do it or you don't have anyone to take the time to keep explaining it. Well you have no exscuses right now. I am willing to teach it "for free" and It is very very very very easy & very very very usefull! Not the like before, but works the same almost.
     
  8. 25(2)+2

    25(2)+2 Trucker Forum STAFF Staff Member

    18,750
    45,476
    Sep 18, 2006
    the road less travelled
    0
    I am going out soon, so I don't have time to debate this with you, I know how it works forward, backward, sideways and inside out, a 2 hour break doesn't work for me and will be dealt with as necessary. By the time I need to stop it takes at least 3 and possibly 4.5 hours of sleep to restore me. These are multiples of 1.5 hours, which fits a natural sleep cycle, unlike 2 hours which emphatically does not. The rules were designed to be easy for LEOs to understand, not to be effective for a driver to obtain needed rest. These rules are compromises and they sure do compromise sleep.


    You state that it's simple and yes it is but it's also not effective for many drivers, there was an article in a March Trucker News about this very thing.
    The Circadian Health Institute did a study (another one); their conclusion is that drivers need more flexibility in sleep and break rules, the older way was inflexible enough and cumbersome enough, this way is just plain idiocy, and some companies won't allow split breaking at all which is taking idiocy to a new level. Split breaking is allowed to make fatigue less of a factor on the road, why not take it the rest of the way. Until the rules are changed, it is still encouraging drivers that are tired to continue driving or lose their drive time for that cycle.
     
  9. prodriver

    prodriver Bobtail Member

    28
    3
    May 14, 2007
    0
    I'm not feeling much love

    I'll agree but I think your statement is opinionated because your idea of a good wage may be different than a company's. Neither is wrong. You may place a higher value on your time than your company does. If this is the case then find yourself a company that will pay you your worth without violating the HOS regulations.


    I'll give some free advice......always log and run legally and I'll assure you all that you'll never end up on that "log".


    I have been in the trucking industry for well over 20 years and I've had the opprotunity to have worked in several positions to include driving and dispatching. I really think that you all are giving your operations people too much credit. Although I have been accused of unfairly giving out ****loads and starving drivers, I can honestly it was never done deliberately. In all honestly, I never had the time to intentionally screw a driver. Most days I had too many loads and too few drivers. This is a good problem for upper management but a terrible problem for dispatchers. Starving drivers is not in the best interest of the company or in the personal best interest of the dispatcher. Personally speaking, it would not be worth the headaches. If you have a problem with a dispatcher, then you should communicate the problems and try to work things out instead of letting it sit on your mind, getting mad and raising your BP.
    Hourly pay does not ensure compliance. It just creates OTHER HOS issues for both drivers and companies. Throwing more money at drivers will not solve all the problems with HOS compliance. Been there. Done that too!

    And a driver is not legally or morally bound to work for them either.


    I want compliance because I want to ensure your safety and the safety of everyoen who uses our country's highways. You seem to think that drivers should be paid to be safe. Just how much money will it take to ensure drivers stay in compliance with the HOS regulations?

    Safety is everyone's responsibility.
     
  10. prodriver

    prodriver Bobtail Member

    28
    3
    May 14, 2007
    0
    Add these to your list too:

    DOT Roadside inspections,
    Toll receipts
    Random drug screens,
    BOLs and company generated travel documents

    All of these are easy pickings for a DOT official conducting an audit.
     
  11. Bullwinkle

    Bullwinkle Medium Load Member

    594
    29
    Jun 11, 2006
    Texas
    0
    Simple. Put drivers on an annual salary that is complete with regular annual raises.

    In addition, you can then keep the hours of service in place because now, once a driver has sit around in a crappy truckstop all day waiting for a load (that you claim you always have too many of, but not enough drivers), when that driver finally gets his/her 450 mile load dispatched to them late in the after noon, loade by 8:00 pm that night, the driver can tell the dispatcher that there is simply no way that the load will be deliverd at 8:00am the following morning because he has been up all day and once the load is loaded they are going back to the truck stop and going to sleep, rather than running the load overnight when they have been up all day already waiting on a load.

    You can preach your "safety" all day long, but the most fatigued and unsafe I have ever been was when trying to make money on these BS loads after sitting all day, then having a dispatch tell me I "need" to make this overnight run because I have plenty hours to do it.

    With a salary, the driver doesn't have to worry about being starved out of the company for standing up to the dispatcher and saying "no" to this insane demand of making the above overnight run. You can claim it doesn't happen, but we all know it does.
     
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.