Automatic or Manual for the Road Test?

Discussion in 'Questions From New Drivers' started by LeadFootHauler, Oct 4, 2012.

  1. LeadFootHauler

    LeadFootHauler Bobtail Member

    42
    10
    Sep 20, 2012
    Hometown, USA
    0
    Dear TR Forum:

    I am in the process of selecting a CDL School. My goal is to drive a tanker so I can avoid a lot of backing up. Which is the best type of transmission to use to take the DMV road test, a manual or automatic transmission? Which is easier to drive with in general? I can drive a manual transmission but have virtually no experience driving a tractor-trailer.

    Thanks,

    LeadFoot View attachment 36994
     

    Attached Files:

  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. btrucker

    btrucker Bobtail Member

    40
    14
    Sep 30, 2012
    Jacksonville, FL
    0
    In my opinion driving an auto transmission is better and easier than a manual. I have a auto transmission now and it really helps in traffic.
     
    LeadFootHauler Thanks this.
  4. TRKRSHONEY

    TRKRSHONEY Heavy Load Member

    726
    420
    Apr 23, 2009
    Knoxville, TN
    0
    Check your state and see if they put a restricition on your CDL if you use an automatic to test, some do which might lead to problems if the company you want to work for has only manual's.
     
    LeadFootHauler Thanks this.
  5. Calspring

    Calspring Light Load Member

    290
    144
    Jun 22, 2012
    Canada
    0
    I have never heard a difinitive answer if you are allowed to drive an automated for your road test. Some people have said you can but lots say that the school wont let you try. I would argue that having to test in a manual is best because not everywhere you will go runs automated and then you would be SOL your first day at a new company.

    I would think under ideal circumstances the school should let you drive both. That way when you are first driving use you the automated. That way you can focus on maintaining speed and lane postion, then once you are comfortable with that you can move on to the manual and work on shifting while in traffic.

    I have heard the same as what btrucker said. If you spend most of your day in traffic then an automated is the way to go as you will not find yourself tired from having to up and downshift for every light and in traffic jams.

    Many people say that knowing how to drive a manual transmission car can actually be a detriment when learning to drive a truck as they are not the same and you have to force yourself to relearn everything.
     
    LeadFootHauler Thanks this.
  6. GasHauler

    GasHauler Master FMCSA Interpreter

    6,257
    4,365
    Oct 23, 2005
    Vegas/Jersey
    0


    What makes you think that you will not back a tanker? You get the truck into position to unload and sometimes the only way out is backing. Here's the best advice I could give. LEARN all you can about the truck and driving while you can. Do not limit yourself.
     
  7. dptrucker

    dptrucker Road Train Member

    4,681
    3,197
    May 14, 2012
    adelanto,ca.
    0
    yep.. what gashauler said. why limit yourself. learn all you can now while ur in school. anybody can drive an automatic. and don,t think you won,t back up..there,ll be times where you,ll have no choice.i know here if calif. you,ll be restricted to auto if you test in one. what will you do if the company decides to get manual. just something for you to trhink about.
     
    TRKRSHONEY and LeadFootHauler Thank this.
  8. Brownsfan16

    Brownsfan16 Medium Load Member

    340
    40
    Sep 7, 2011
    0
    I know in Ohio you can test in either. I did all of my driving training before the test in a manual. Once the test came though everyone takes the test in a automatic just because it's obviously less nerve racking when you don't have to worry about shifting or stalling a truck.

    I had great fun learning how to use a manual transmission though and am so glad I got to experience how both work.

    I will also add that I think this might go into law in a couple years nationwide that if you test in a automatic you can then only drive a automatic. I could be wrong on this but that was something I heard when I was in school.
     
    LeadFootHauler Thanks this.
  9. passion4polishing

    passion4polishing Road Train Member

    1,249
    921
    Mar 7, 2012
    Tampa, FL
    0
    Whether you drive a manual or auto isn't that important, and auto drivers are still truckers. That being said, all drivers should know how to drive a manual. You never know when you're gonna need that skill, and once you get it down it shouldn't make your test much harder to do it in a manual.
     
    TRKRSHONEY and LeadFootHauler Thank this.
  10. morr2fab

    morr2fab Medium Load Member

    338
    110
    Oct 3, 2012
    0
    In NH if you test in an automatic you will have that restriction on your license. Then if you want to get rid of that restriction you have to retest all over again, pre trip, skills and road test. I know, I had to. Plus the manual is far better on gas and forward control on the highway. But if your buzzing around in the city, an auto is much better. Auto is great for class B trucks an many new ones now come with autos. Ps, work on that backing thing, you'll be glad you did.
     
    LeadFootHauler Thanks this.
  11. RAGE 18

    RAGE 18 Road Train Member

    1,529
    941
    Jan 31, 2011
    GOLD£N☆STAT£
    0
    automatics take all the fun in driving...im in one now n it took a while getting used to it its like ur in control but ur not i dont know if that makes any sense to u. Best advice is learn everything u can including manual n as far as the backing up part, well this career is like learning to drive a car all over again u are required to be competent in all areas. good luck bro.
     
    LeadFootHauler Thanks this.
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.