Moving Air compressor intake out of intake manifold?

Discussion in 'Trucks [ Eighteen Wheelers ]' started by Flightline, Jan 8, 2013.

  1. Flightline

    Flightline Road Train Member

    2,345
    1,165
    Oct 1, 2011
    Almost There
    0
    There is no doubt the cat engineers know alot about the engines but these engines are designed as multi purpose engine for more than trucks but also for marine and especially off road equipment.
    Especially in 1999, fuel economy or effeceinty was not a priorty over multi use engine.
    These compressor intake was put into the intake maniford, so as not to be specific to a truck but installed on the engine before ever installed in the truck.
    I did have a previous truck (Detroit engine) but same set up and the turbo blew apart and peices went into the compressor and took it out.
    Moving this would prevent this happening. (Maybe)
     
  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. SmokinCAT

    SmokinCAT Road Train Member

    1,773
    1,487
    Oct 20, 2010
    Hillsboro, OH./ Adrian, MI
    0
    The turbo pieces would have to make it through your aftercooler for that to happen now.

    Have you ever stuck your hand in front of your turbo at an idle with the intake tube off? There is negative pressure, and thats not even at full boost. You are not loosing boost to the air compressor, nor are you loosing fuel economy.

    They were put in the intake so the compressor will always have a clean supply of warm air.
     
    cetanediesel Thanks this.
  4. allan5oh

    allan5oh Road Train Member

    1,557
    556
    Jan 6, 2010
    Winnipeg, mb
    0
    I'm about 99% sure it doesn't draw air unless it's compressing anyways.
     
    cetanediesel Thanks this.
  5. special k

    special k Light Load Member

    89
    38
    Sep 6, 2008
    Ontario Canada
    0
    You can do it but it's probably not worth your time. I put a bigger compressor on my CAT and it's set up to be "naturally aspirated" meaning the supply air shouldn'd be foced in like it is when it comes from the intake manifold. I was told by Bendix to put the air pickup it as close as possible to the air cleaner or to run a seperate air filter so that the air would be more stable. They said if it was too close to the turbo it could try to suck air/oil out of the air compressor under boost. They told me some trucks with EGR have n/a compressors because the exhaust gasses in the intake mixture were causing issues with compressors. Don't forget a lot of OLD cat came from the factory like that. They just had a small round filter bolted to the side of the compressor.
     
    Flightline Thanks this.
  6. Flightline

    Flightline Road Train Member

    2,345
    1,165
    Oct 1, 2011
    Almost There
    0
    If we go by the theory: Cat engineers know more than we can, why put bigge turbo's on?, why take egr's off?, why have ecm's reflashed for better economy?.

    I will agree with changing the compressor intake probably on makes .01 percent maybe less difference. But also wouldn't be real hard and cheap to do.

    Not meaning to knock cat engineers, I question changing anything from orginal several times before acting on it. That is why I bring up this thread.
     
  7. ENR

    ENR Light Load Member

    254
    50
    Oct 8, 2009
    Ontario
    0
    If i'm in a pull my boost can drop 3-4 psi when the compressor starts up. I've considered this mod myself but I'm worried the compressor won't be able to keep up with my trains if the air isn't being crammed in there. I'm interested in hearing how this goes for you.
     
    Flightline Thanks this.
  8. swaan

    swaan Road Train Member

    2,942
    4,374
    Jul 12, 2009
    BC canada
    0
    You guys in my opinion are over thinking this. If you really think you have to convert the the compressor over to atmosphere intake, bendix makes a filter that bolts on to the intake of the compressor. It's in there catalog. Although I really think its a moot point as there is no reason to change it over.
     
    cetanediesel Thanks this.
  9. Bent Wrench

    Bent Wrench Medium Load Member

    588
    205
    Aug 11, 2009
    Cornholio, OR
    0
    How much of that boost loss is due to the increased load on the motor or other factors unrelated to the compressors actual affect on manifold pressure? Small turbo maxed out? Large turbo falling out of it's sweet spot?

    I would do a test, switching the compressor intake to verify your conclusion.
     
  10. ROBSREDFORD

    ROBSREDFORD Light Load Member

    266
    139
    Sep 2, 2008
    MIDLAND, NC
    0
    My.02.....I do it on all the trucks I keep. Less heat on compressor....less boost loss.... Builds air fine. Cat engineers are not the ones with compressor knowledge..... Try bendix.....cfm will be lower without boost.....particularly on acerts..... But the problems with the carbon in the brass valves and the line charging the tanks go from frequent to virtually non existent..... To me the pluses outweigh any minus. RW
     
    Flightline Thanks this.
  11. allan5oh

    allan5oh Road Train Member

    1,557
    556
    Jan 6, 2010
    Winnipeg, mb
    0
    I would say it's more compressor heat if anything. The turbocharger is actually a very efficient way to compress air. Far more efficient than any air compressor. Without it the air compressor does more work because it takes a lot longer to build up air.
     
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.