Cheating on logs

Discussion in 'Trucking Industry Regulations' started by dogtrucker, Dec 6, 2013.

  1. NewbiusErectus

    NewbiusErectus Medium Load Member

    586
    615
    Jun 27, 2012
    0
    my logging has less to do with obeying DOT. it's all about what dinomite said in his post: The accident that may happen where someone gets killed, and I'm not at fault -- Or -- i wasn't at fault until the prosecutor or opposing attorney goes thru my days prior to that with a fine tooth comb.

    People like to brag about getting one over on the DOT ociffer. That's easy. When you get one over on the well-educated guy who stands to earn 5, 6, or 7+ figures for finding something wrong with your logs after an accident, then you've accomplished something.

    Being new, there's a lot to learn and the majority is CYA. Do I bend rules? Probably. I just know that if something does happen, the most they will likely find will be in the gray areas and not blatant falsification. It will also be something that, even tho im on paper, I could have done on elogs.

    So, by one of your responses in this thread, I know you don't like the "when someone dies" answer. But IF someone dies, you'll probably be going to jail. I'm definitely not a goody two shoe person, and i'll be the last person to throw stones at people who run illegal. But I've put a lot of thought into repercussions of illegal logs, and it just comes down to .. Is it worth the few extra bucks?
     
    road_runner, Dinomite and tirednaz Thank this.
  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. "Hang - Man"

    "Hang - Man" Heavy Load Member

    737
    583
    Nov 12, 2013
    Western PA
    0
    Sorry but i think they will find something wrong no matter what --if you read a lot of threads you realize no one can agree on what some of the rules mean let alone the interpretation of some of them.
    Oh yeh not to mention what they will find wrong with the truck --which in turn is your fault for not seeing it ---"Hanged"
     
  4. tsavory

    tsavory Road Train Member

    1,910
    1,860
    Jun 4, 2013
    Paoli, IN
    0

    I will agree a Good driver don't need to cheat.
    But even Good drivers do stretch the truth from time to time.
    And Great drivers don't hide from it and log as they do it I for one will never get stuck in Penn when I did the responsible thing and slept for 3 hrs when I was tiered but it meant I got to the shipper 30 min past my 14 I won't hide and its marked noted and DOT seen it and was very happy I was honest and safe. now don't get me wrong there are those that will be picky but most are more unhappy when they find out you lied.


    as to his reasons I can see them I mean come on what other profession does it tell when you work how you work when your tired and not?
    How often do you get 30 min or less from your end point and have to stop and take a 30 min break? Twice to me just last week you think that gives me the REST i need? or would getting there shutting down and taking my ten (45 min earlier 30min break 15 getting parked and get started again).

    I for one am a 5 to 6 hour sleeper I can't sleep past that so do the 11-14 hours exhausted so sleep up in six sit for 4 tired from boredom then got to drive yeah thats safe!
    OH yeah and lets not forget new 34 hr restart Now I have to wait till 5am Mon morning and oops 2 problems one either direction I go I am in rush hour traffic st 7 am and 2 between 5 and 7 no matter if I have been up 1 hr or 15 I have a hard time keeping my eyes opened its just the way I have always been.

    Lets try to do something to help change these rules and regulations (not Laws by the way) and cheating them is not it.
     
    Last edited: Dec 6, 2013
  5. Lepton1

    Lepton1 Road Train Member

    12,647
    25,588
    Nov 23, 2012
    Yukon, OK
    0
    It IS unnecessary to log on duty while being loaded or unloaded. DOT clarified that rule a few months ago. You only need to log when you are actually on duty. I log when I arrive at the shipper/receiver and check in, when I'm opening doors and backing into the dock, when I'm getting out of a dock and closing and locking the doors, etc. However, when I'm in my tractor while being loaded or unloaded I'm Off Duty. That's how the new clarification works. During live loads or unloads my total On Duty time should be no more than about 30 minutes, but split up over however long the total process takes. Therefore the only impact a long live load/unload takes is on your 14, not on your 11 or 70.
     
  6. bubbanbrenda

    bubbanbrenda Road Train Member

    1,388
    650
    Feb 27, 2011
    Middletown,Oh.
    0
    Other then that be prepared to spend time with bubba.

    I would prefer you leave me out of this.
     
  7. NewbiusErectus

    NewbiusErectus Medium Load Member

    586
    615
    Jun 27, 2012
    0
    [QUOTE="Hang - Man";3697665]Sorry but i think they will find something wrong no matter what --if you read a lot of threads you realize no one can agree on what some of the rules mean let alone the interpretation of some of them.
    Oh yeh not to mention what they will find wrong with the truck --which in turn is your fault for not seeing it ---"Hanged"[/QUOTE]

    I agree 100%. That's why I said the most they will find will be in grey areas. What they won't find is blatant violations, like driving 5 hours over limit. I'm at least going to make them do SOMETHING to earn their money :-D Like, convince a jury that I shouldn't have been logged in sleeper after the unloader told me to crash out if I want.
     
    "Hang - Man" Thanks this.
  8. dogtrucker

    dogtrucker Road Train Member

    1,102
    1,138
    Sep 10, 2012
    my truck
    0

    I wasn't the one one to respond to "when some one dies" because it was an irrelevant comment.
    I did not make the whole "safety speech" in my intro because no one I want to talk to is the kind of person who needs to hear that one more time.
    How does logging off-duty or sleeper at a shipper put one at risk in an accident situation?
    One of my main objections and something I want to get around if possible is being pressured to drive fatigued by the 14hr rule.

    We shouldn't be antagonistic or jump to negative unfounded assumptions. We could help each other by sharing info - what this site is about. If some strategies are a bad idea it is helpful to know; if others (such as doing VI's off duty in most states) are doable - there are drivers who need to know that as well.

    Personally, I'll be fairly tolerant of rhetoric - even mush headed preachers types - if they would just have some info relevant to the thread. But no, most just like to jack-off in public.

    Which-is-who is easily discernible by the quality (and relevancy) of the responses
     
    Last edited: Dec 6, 2013
  9. dogtrucker

    dogtrucker Road Train Member

    1,102
    1,138
    Sep 10, 2012
    my truck
    0
    That is basically what I suspected from my reading of the FMCSA but I work for a company that tells us we have to be on duty and looks the other way when we are not. Also, many shippers are "Driver Load ans Count" and will even say that on the bills. Nevertheless, the don't really want you on the dock. That requires a driver to be on-duty but, far as I can tell, the D.O.T. does not care.

    See, it's f**** up convolutions like that which are part of the purpose of this thread.

    Thanks for your post
     
  10. Lepton1

    Lepton1 Road Train Member

    12,647
    25,588
    Nov 23, 2012
    Yukon, OK
    0
    Swift put out a video clarifying the rule for On Duty time during loads and unloads. Might want to ask your company again to revisit that rule. If indeed you are officially required by your company to log On Duty time then that is an incorrect interpretation on their part. Have them do more research on it.
     
  11. "Hang - Man"

    "Hang - Man" Heavy Load Member

    737
    583
    Nov 12, 2013
    Western PA
    0
    I think this forum needs a step by step instruction's on how to (they may be posted somewhere already) fill out electronic logs to maximize a drivers money making time -gray areas and all.
    I see to many threads where everyone rambles on about how they do legal logs --yet next post they wonder why they cant make any money.
    I know you just have to stretch the truth on the electronic logs --all the hints tips what ever they may be.
     
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.