I did my pretrip and found my alternator and belt tensioner died. Since I drove to the closes dealer for parts, I did a vir. Called in to breakdown to get it cleared. Since I do my own work I had no way to fax them "proof" I fixed it. He says it not illegal to say nothings wrong with when there is but it is illegal for him to clear it without proof but "he'd do it for me at his own personal risk" and "expect it to happen every time I mark it and fix it myself". Seriously? I wonder what Mr DOT would say if I marked it as OK and got dot'd on my way for parts. Hmmm.
seriously?
Discussion in 'Ask An Owner Operator' started by Steeleandsonfarms, May 2, 2014.
Page 1 of 5
-
-
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
-
What idiot told you that? You signing its been fixed is the only "proof" that has ever been needed by the dot.
-
But, you better have logged that it as on duty not driving. -
You are also allowed to drive to the nearest repair facility if you can safely do so. If your belt is still turning but no alternator charging I would say one can safely drive easily a half hour on 4 batteries if not more. How are you sure the alternator died? A bad tensioner and the belt could be slipping giving the appearance the alternator was bad. While your motor is turning 750 rpms the alternator could be turning 500 rpms which is not enough to generate 14V. I would of replaced the belt and tensioner and retested the alternator.
It's in 396.3 I believe the company has to keep records of repairs for like a year. You have to give them something in case of an audit. Find you a form to use as a record of repair just like a shop does with a work order. Purchasing parts doesn't show what truck it went on. For all the company knows is you have a well stocked garage at home.I'm sure there is a form on the internet you can print off. Another thing the DOT might look at if something happens is this guy qualified as a mechanic? They look at someone being a mechanic as someone that is certified or has at least one year work experience turning a wrench. Have you been working on diesel equipment 1 year? Get in a fatality and they'll look at this stuff. CYA!
Another thing you can do is take pictures of before, during and after. They can't argue that. -
Who is the "he" that your speaking of? I dont believe there is a law that says you have to be a qualified mechanic to change an alternator and tensioner. I know many guys including myself that are far more competent than what I have seen in some shops. As long as it is fixed properly I dont think its any of there concern how it got fixed, except for brakes in some circumstances.
Steeleandsonfarms Thanks this. -
boy do some people over think things
EverLuc, RedForeman and jbatmick Thank this. -
the guy owns his own truck, its his. and I have never ever logged on duty when I am repairing my own equipment. so its perfectly fine for him to repair his own equipment.
on the vir there is a blank to sign that all reapairs have been made.
remember there can sometimes be to much information.
what I would have done was went on personal conveyance going to get the part and while I repaired it.EverLuc Thanks this. -
Yes, I own my own truck. If I repair it on the road, and not noted it on the inspection, then it is just done by magic. If I noted on the form, then I show that I was on duty. -
Two years diesel mechanics schooling. My truck. I was not involved in the operation of a cmv when I changed. I crawled out took off my drivers hat, put on my mechanics hat and fixed it. Everything was silent on the 5 minute cool down idle and post trip. Pretrip looked good started it to a god awful screaming and rattling noise. Belt tensioner locked up solid and the alternator shaft bearing was out. 1/8" slop in it. Still charging fine but those two things explained the .5mpg decrease on the last tank. Pulled the belt so it didn't shred. Not my first rodeo wrenching. The fact I "need proof" that is next to impossible to provide is bad but telling me to mark it as OK struck me funny.
FYI Brakes, engine, transmission, and clutch are all shop done for warranty and liability purposes. -
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
Page 1 of 5