What engine with DEF is having the least amount of problems?

Discussion in 'Trucks [ Eighteen Wheelers ]' started by Notchpeak, Aug 6, 2016.

  1. Star4900

    Star4900 Medium Load Member

    607
    521
    Mar 16, 2015
    Northern Ontario
    0
    Notchpeak, I can say this, I love the layout of my Star 4900. Lots of room inside, very quiet, no squeaks or rattles, awesome smooth ride and handles very good. I love the dash layout. Lots of room for every gauge you can think of. Good switch work. Awesome stereo. And I really like the Data Star compared to most in-dash info displays. I really want to love this truck if it wasn't for the shoddy build quality issues it came with. Not acceptable considering they have "premium" pricing.
    I have recently seen a lot of lemons come out of their factory, and I have friends that bought them and had no issues? Our 2003 High rise float tractor was built much better with better quality components.
    I would buy another though.
    We also have a 2012 Coronado SD122 and it is a really nice truck too. Had better build quality. It is also very quiet, smooth riding and comfy. The dash info display sucks though. Confusing to use. All the issues we had with that truck were Cummins ISX failures.
    Out of all the new engines, I prefer the Detroit's. Mine has been bulletproof, other than emission sensor failures. But no hard parts have been touched. It has way more torque down low compared to our ISX600, despite it being only a 505/1650. They both get the same fuel mileage. But I like how the Detroit pulls like an old Cat down low.
    I have a few friends with MP8 and MP10 Mack's and they have been working very well also.
    The most problems I see at my dealers are Cummins and Maxxforce. Don't have any Paccars around here.
     
    rachi, Grijon and Notchpeak Thank this.
  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. Notchpeak

    Notchpeak Bobtail Member

    13
    1
    Aug 6, 2016
    0
    Thank you. Full of great information. I did hear that freight liner bought western star and turned it into a freightliner. That's to bad western star had a great reputation. So the Coronado is better build quality then your western star? I haven't heard a ton of horror stories about the Detroit's so that's what I'm starting to lean towards again. I only hear a little about the paccar so I don't have a huge opinion on it yet.
     
  4. Star4900

    Star4900 Medium Load Member

    607
    521
    Mar 16, 2015
    Northern Ontario
    0
    Well, in my case yes....but that's only two trucks. Seems like it's almost a coin toss when it comes to buying a new truck. Some are built right, but for some reason it's just not consistent.
    I have a few friends that are mechanics at dealers and I hear the same from them, seems to be less issues with the DD Detroit's. Plus they seems to give less hassle with warranty issues than Cummins. At least in my town anyway.
    There are a couple fleets up north of me that run Paccar MX500's and they are happy with them. But I hear they are having problems with camshafts. But they say they pull well and are good on fuel. They are used as dump trucks, and tractors pulling logs and 5 axle acid tankers.
    But I don't have any Paccar dealers around me, so even dealers I spoke to said they wouldn't sell me a truck with a Paccar for that reason.
    It's too bad, because I'd like to try a T-880.
     
    Notchpeak Thanks this.
  5. AModelCat

    AModelCat Road Train Member

    29,167
    158,713
    Jul 7, 2015
    Canuckistan
    0
    They use Yanmar and Mitsubishi engines as well. Some of their telescopic forklifts are JLG and most of their vertical mast forklifts are Mitsubishi. I swear their mini excavators are yellow Yanmars but I need confirmation on that.
     
  6. Notchpeak

    Notchpeak Bobtail Member

    13
    1
    Aug 6, 2016
    0
    I've had people tell me to try the t880 also. I have a 12 Pete with a paccar I was looking at buying that's why I posted on here to get more info on the newer trucks. All I know for sure is I'll stay away from the Isx.
     
  7. Star4900

    Star4900 Medium Load Member

    607
    521
    Mar 16, 2015
    Northern Ontario
    0
    Wow, I knew about them using Mitsubishi engines and excavators for years, but didn't know about Yanmar.

    Not to sidetrack the thread.....but have you ever looked at their compact wheel loaders, then at the comparable new Kubota R630? I almost wonder if they are built in the same factory, because they sure look similar.
     
  8. Star4900

    Star4900 Medium Load Member

    607
    521
    Mar 16, 2015
    Northern Ontario
    0
    I gotta give a disclaimer again, because I don't want to be one these keyboard warriors that condems every truck because one had an issue. My thoughts are only what I've experienced with the trucks I've owned and driven.
     
    Notchpeak Thanks this.
  9. Notchpeak

    Notchpeak Bobtail Member

    13
    1
    Aug 6, 2016
    0
    I agree with you. All trucks have problems, even the good ol cats did. I'm just looking for the best option now.
     
  10. AModelCat

    AModelCat Road Train Member

    29,167
    158,713
    Jul 7, 2015
    Canuckistan
    0
    We've got a couple new 924K Cats in our fleet but that's about it. I haven't seen a small Kubota loader before though.
     
  11. Star4900

    Star4900 Medium Load Member

    607
    521
    Mar 16, 2015
    Northern Ontario
    0
    They're the 906M Northern Mechanic. 906M.jpg 016868.jpg 906M.jpg 016868.jpg 906M.jpg 016868.jpg 906M.jpg 016868.jpg
     
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.