Rand McNally 510,s 520..ect Be Careful

Discussion in 'Trucking Electronics, Gadgets and Software Forum' started by waveform, Dec 8, 2016.

  1. Mark Kling

    Mark Kling Technology Contributor

    10,935
    4,212
    Sep 23, 2007
    Statesville, NC
    0
    If has been just completed then it can take a year or two to get into the map database.

    Maps will never be 100% perfect..
     
  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. Mark Kling

    Mark Kling Technology Contributor

    10,935
    4,212
    Sep 23, 2007
    Statesville, NC
    0
    35.446935, -80.606839 This is exit 58 sb.... this is where it should be?
     
  4. Driver0000

    Driver0000 Medium Load Member

    304
    320
    Jun 26, 2016
    0
    I'm not sure it's exit 58.

    It's a new bridge. The original bridge is a little north of the new bridge. Every time I have to exit on it, my RM goes nuts at the top of the ramp.

    One time I turned right when my destination was to the left. That was the time the GPS wanted to take me waaaaay down the road to turn around using a highway ramp when there were several alternative "go around a block" routes.

    Like I said, I use the RM and a phone together to help keep me on a good route.

    The only issue with my RM that has really bothered me is when it shuts down and shows no battery when it's plugged in.

    This has happened to me on three occasions in three separate trucks.

    It hasn't happened in a few months but having it happen in a major city sucked
     
  5. Mark Kling

    Mark Kling Technology Contributor

    10,935
    4,212
    Sep 23, 2007
    Statesville, NC
    0

    As I have mentioned before,,, Many times the smaller roads are not set for trucks and you visually will see a way, but legally you cannot. Roads have many variables that you don't know about build into the segments such as "weight" of road, this will determine to the router if it will use this as a primary route or you will just not be routed on it. "0" means no go. RM can massage the data sometimes to show a preference to routing so you cannot be routed on a "No Truck" route.

    But in the end it is how HERE has the variables set in the map database. Google Maps or Bing Maps do not take these into account.

    Car mode it will route you, but not in truck mode - truck restriction.
    Car mode it will not route you - map issue.

    Anytime construction is done, until it is signed off by the state it is still considered construction and once signed off it may take a year or two to be entered into the map databases whereas Google Maps uses satellites to obtain street views. Google Maps you use their servers so the data can be changed and you will see it. Stand alone GPS units retain their maps internally and cannot be changed until the next map update.

    Are the map databases perfect - nope and never will be as it entails a lot of data entry.

    As far as the power issue, there is a support thread for the TND's for this type of issues.

    If you remember the exit let me know.

    Mark
     
  6. waveform

    waveform Light Load Member

    81
    54
    Feb 21, 2014
    California
    0
    Your missing the point Mark Kling. And if you don't believe I got a hold of the VP, you're wrong.
    • Firstly, my GPS is set to car mode, because I have to drive in residential arias. So that eliminates most of what you said regarding reasons why it can't navigate certain roads. The thing makes too many mistakes. On the reservations, it's almost never able to find address. Google maps, no problem.
    • Second, I never expedited the CEO or VP to address issues personally. I'm not that simple. I expect them to have the authority to take a large issue like this seriously and at least have some integrity to let me speak to their engineers, (Like I was told I was going to) The fact that he was arrogant and didn't return my call, or that they're not open to professional drivers: Will be exposed to the world.
    • And what ever you want to say about GoogleMaps, is fine. But in the real world, I have a job to do and I'm amazed that I can find any of the address in Pala, Rincon, VallyCenter, Fallbrook, Vista, Rainbow, Escondido California, with google maps, but my 300 dollar GPS misses roads that have been there for 20+ years even after the latest updates. Some roads don't even show up while I'm driving on them. This happens too often. I work in an industry where drivers don't have time to use maps. Tomorrow morning I have to hammer out 48 stops in Fallbrook, and Vista CA. Towns that are huge and broken up by mountains. I really hate when people like myself try to do the right thing to better products by taking an extra leap, and people like you come back at me like I'm not seeing the big picture. The problem is, Rand McNally uses Thomas maps company to do their surveying, as in the case with most consumer GPS units also. Maybe the VP or CEO has the power to appoint the right people to look into what google is using. None of the issues I've wasted time entering into the GPS has ever been resolved in over three years, and possibly not even read.
    Please understand that, not everyone just drives around in a car and only enters their friends address into their GPS every six months. The point is, they are calling this a truckers certified professional GPS, and I'm telling you the thing sucks. The only thing that makes the RandMcNally GPS units nice, is the sturdy mount and a few other features that I actually really like about them. I see a lot of potential with their GPS units, but it frustrates me that they don't care to listen to someone who is trying to help them. I'm sorry, but its horrible with finding address in the towns I've named, which is a large part of southern CA. I drove from Chicago to San Diago and my family was telling me to throw the thing out the window. We ended up using our phones to get out of a few harry situations. It's absurd. You can defend them all you want, who knows maybe you work for them. But I'm a propane driver in the towns I named, and I'm telling you this thing sucks.

    The fact that the other GPS brands are no better is not a reason for someone like myself to not try and attempt to help a company out. But when a company is too arrogant to let someone like myself (who is a professional driver who services over 15 thousands customers - not just some general consumer) who has tried as hard as me to reach someone at the top. This clearly shows that the company has no interest to try to resolve issues. It's easier to just advertise a bunch of nonsense clamming that their GPS is "Trucker Certified" Welcome to the new world of mass marketing mass consumption.

    I don't care if you agree with me, You're obviously not a driver if you're defending them. And if you are, you should trying driving a propane truck and see how easy it is to knock out 40 to 50 will call stops a day with one of these. There are statistics and then there is the real world. I'm out there working - Not doing technology reviews that mean absolutely nothing. Get out there and do it. I would love to see you do what I do every day and see how your attitude would be. But it sounds like you sit behind a desk and play with GPS's.
     
    Last edited: Dec 15, 2016
  7. LGarrison

    LGarrison Road Train Member

    1,246
    995
    May 19, 2011
    Sandpoint Idaho
    0
    You must use common sense take it off the shortest route that screws you up every time put it on the fastest route and you won't have those problems
    Mark King works his butt off for us and I for one thank him
     
    Mark Kling Thanks this.
  8. Pedigreed Bulldog

    Pedigreed Bulldog Road Train Member

    7,737
    14,408
    May 7, 2011
    0
    So if the 510 was junk, why buy the 520? I can understand buying an updated device from the same brand if you were HAPPY with the old one...hell, when my outdated 465T finally died, I bought a dezl570LMT because I was satisfied with the service I had received from my first Garmin. Had it been junk, or if the map was inaccurate (besides being seriously out-of-date...I couldn't see paying as much for a map update as what a new device cost, and I didn't NEED a new device because it still worked...), then I would have tried a Rand or Tom Tom or one from any other GPS maker OTHER THAN the one I was unhappy with. That's what I find odd...you were unhappy with the 510, so you bought the 520. Glutten for punishment? Or do you just enjoy having something to complain about?
     
  9. Mark Kling

    Mark Kling Technology Contributor

    10,935
    4,212
    Sep 23, 2007
    Statesville, NC
    0
    Click above to see added input.

    All in all your issue is not with the Rand McNally, but the simple fact that roads are missing in the HERE Map Database.

    So give me a list of some of the roads you say the RM cannot find to include the Indian Reservations.

    No need to talk to a VP or CEO, if you simply posted on the support thread that you were having issues finding roads that are not on the HERE Maps I could have looked on Production Maps and then verified on the next set of maps. If they were missing I then would go to Google Maps and find the Lat/Long and simply enter a ticket into the JIRA Ticket system for RM which is compiled and then sent to HERE to have them verify and entered into the Here Map Database.

    So give me a list. Since you make deliveries you should have some record of the streets.

    Mark
     
    waveform Thanks this.
  10. waveform

    waveform Light Load Member

    81
    54
    Feb 21, 2014
    California
    0
    Common sense? I don't know where you got the idea that I use the shortest route. I never use that, and I sure never said that. I said, I keep my RM GPS set to car mode since I drive a propane truck an need to go into residential neighborhoods. Nice try LGarrison


    You know, you guys are unbelievable. This is what I mean. You guys are trying so hard to prove me wrong that you're not even understanding the points I'm making. Well I'll answer your question again: I bought the 520 when I was in training for Propane. Before that, I owned the 510 when I lived in Chicago, and it worked wonderful. But Chicago is a totally different animal than SoCA. If you people are taking shots at me because I disagreed with Mark Kling, you don't need to defend him - He's already earned my respect.

    Thanks for offering this Mark. I will gladly do that. I will need to compile a list, because I don't do that anymore. The roads I've actually taken the time to send have already been uploaded to RM. But the unit still doesn't see them. I'm telling you, Propane is a crazy industry. We have 7 drivers and 15,000 customers. Now that it's winter, we're being slammed with work and out of gas calls. I don't even have time to stop and eat. So I don't keep a list of streets because I honestly don't have time, but I will make time.

    I will gladly do this and then look you up to give you the list Mark.
    But I honestly don't think it is the solution to this issue. After all, if I'm taking the time to make a list of roads, I'd just as well memorize them. I need a GPS that will find roads for me that I don't know. I am new to these areas. And making a list so RM can add layers is a nice start, but it's impossible for me to find all the thousands of roads that I am soon to encounter. If you have to go to google maps to find these streets, doesn't that seem to be an issue all by itself? Why is the info present in google maps, but not with the maps RM is using? I wish google made their own GPS.
     
    Last edited: Dec 16, 2016
  11. LGarrison

    LGarrison Road Train Member

    1,246
    995
    May 19, 2011
    Sandpoint Idaho
    0
    He just needs more wine with his GPS
     
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.