It's easy to see which cummins ISX hp engine you have because of the spec plate on valve cover. Check it out. I decided against that Volvo D12 and got an ISX 500 in a 2006 Volvo vn 780. I couldn't help but spend the extra required for the spacious cab of the vn780, but the vn670 is also nice to drive. In any case, I ended up spending dyno money on both a 465hp Volvo D12 and on a 500hpCumminsISX, both in the same vn780 chassis and both 13sp (slightly different rear end ratios though). The Volvo D12 was dog. Nominally rated at 465hp, at the wheels 100 hp less--365hp. Although a 13 sp would help, I couldn't see myself restricted to such low hp hauling 80,000 lbs over the Sierra or Rocky Mountains. The Cummins ISX was better in performance, advertised at 500 hp, the computer suggested that the actual hp at the motor was better than 500, while at the wheels it was 440. I don't expect a huge motor, as I will drive below 65 and actually do want fuel economy, but some low hp motors can be frustratingly slow over mountains. The ubiquitous nature of the Cummins engine across the USA was also a big selling point for me. I'm still starting out, so who knows what life span the engine will have. The dyno process is somewhat of a gimmic, to be honest, the way dealers are chummy with your mechanic and all. Good luck in your venture.
Volvo D12 Computer Info Wanted
Discussion in 'Trucks [ Eighteen Wheelers ]' started by stocktonhauler, May 25, 2009.
Page 3 of 3
-
-
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
-
Did you end up buying from Arrow? also did you find out about the 2 year
extension? if there is no extension how much will a retrofit cost to bring
up your current motor to CARB specs.If decide to buy from Arrow I would
like to have someone not connected to Arrow inspect the truck,do they
allow this? keep me posted on how the transaction is going.Thanks for your input.Another Canadian driver Thanks this. -
No, I decided against the D-12 motor, not because it's such a bad motor but because the nominal 365hp as shown by the dyno, but still within specs understand, was just so much lower than I would want. Also, although Volvo is improving it's repair representation across the nation, it's still an exotic engine. I've found better results with a Volvo having a Cummins ISX 500 hp motor, which when dyno appeared to have 440hp at the wheels, and of course, Cummins is everywhere.
Independent inspection by a mechanic, even though it's allowable by law, including independent dyno work is not as easy to accomplish as one might think. The dealers and dyno guys all know each other, and with a wink and a nod, the dyno guy won't hesitate to manipulate his data to help his dealer friend out. There aren't any government standards for dyno testing of commercial trucks, like there are for smog tests on automobiles, which makes the dyno a deceptive artform.
Just be sure to look carefully at everything and find whatever oil leak, worn tire, or shock needs fixing by the dealer before it rolls off the floor. They can do these things cheaper than you. Look around. If the tires on one truck look better than another, get them to swap tires. I swapped for super singles this way.
Also, you can get the print out the pedigree of any truck for free at the Volvo and Cummins dealers--showing all warranty repairs made and remaining warranty coverage. Also, a computer ECM is useful for finding the amount of engine abuse--e.g. excessive water and oil temperatures--as well as the average mpg--but this will cost about $150 at the Cummins dealer, I believe. Work out a package with the Cummins dealer to do a dyno and ECM at the same time, but just make sure they know what hard copy results you require from the dyno.
Best of luck to you too...Another Canadian driver Thanks this. -
We bought from Arrow and hindsight is 20/20. Wish we had gotten the truck inspected by an outside source, we were in a hurry, got the truck delivered to our new employer. What a huge mistake! We are in the truck 3 months now and are still experiencing our huge mistake. Take that truck and by all means get it inspected by an outside mechanic. They will allow it, they won't like it, but they will allow it.
Another Canadian driver Thanks this. -
My EGR just went today... D12 arent the best $1,000 to replace..
Another Canadian driver Thanks this. -
I dynod 3 D12s before buying my truck. And while not seeing that level of drop on any of them, one was at 410 to the rears. Turned out that it still had the company tune on the ECM. The other that I didnt buy had 420 range and a lot of issues. Mine showed 438 to rears.
What I learned as I was buying is that most company trucks get tuned down to reduce power and increase economy. And many of the people doing this do not know what they are doing. Then when it is sold only the speed restriction is removed. There are a lot of things that need to be matched in the ECM to get best power and economy. And I am just talking about changes that a dealer can make, not a special tune to unlock the engine.
So what I learned, when shopping, poor HP at a Dyno may be an easy fix and a way you can get a better price. But you better know that is the case.Another Canadian driver Thanks this. -
The really good computer diagnostic may be done with PTT/VTT ore VCADs pro. You can check injectors, fuel rate, MPG and do compression test with starter.Another Canadian driver Thanks this. -
Anyone know where I can get D12 EGR cooler and valve for good price?
Another Canadian driver Thanks this.
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
Page 3 of 3