Can I still file a claim against a broker's bond if the cargo is damaged?

I would say file on the bond, and then the broker can fight with the customer over getting paid, and the customer can fight with you over the damages. Next time, take pictures. Lots and lots of pictures. Any and all damage gets photographed BEFORE you touch the car. Then, when these claims arise, you have proof to validate your theory that the damage was pre-existing. The broker still needs to pay you, though.

 

The broker still has to pay you the agreed rate. You are responsible to make good with the shipper.
Did you do an inspection noting any & all damages, including mentioned scratches? Do you have signatures at pick up & delivery?

 

And to add to the whole lot of pictures, if you do more vehicle moves, get a decent video camera and video a walk around of the vehicle. Don't use a cell phone camera. You want one that will not blur with movement.