I have a '00 9400 with N14 and 960,000. I've been thinking about getting something newer('06-'07), but after talking to numerous mechanics/drivers and reading stuff on here about how the post '04 engines are less reliable than pre '04 I'm kinda hesitant to get a truck with a post '04 engine. My N14 has been very reliable but it's getting close to needing an OH, so I don't know if I should just do an overhaul and keep running it or take my chances and get a new truck. i've thought about glider kits, but it seems like a completed truck will end up costing as much as a factory built new truck, which isn't in my budget. The cab and chassis on my truck is in pretty good shape with good paint and no structural damage. What do you guys think? I've always liked having new stuff, but with the restrictions on the new motors I'm starting to think that the old stuff is better.
on the fence about buying new truck or overhauling old one
Discussion in 'Trucks [ Eighteen Wheelers ]' started by gunner76, Mar 11, 2010.
Page 1 of 4
-
-
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
-
N14 were always a good engine. I would overhaul it. Just remember, in the not too distance future the laws will kick in for older trucks like this and you may have to install a DPF system.
-
The other option is a getting a rolling glider kit with a pre-emissions engine. You could get, say, a 2010 Coronado or Columbia, spec'd the way you want it, and with a rebuilt pre-emissions Detroit, Cummins, or Cat engine and rebuilt tranny of your choice. All for around $30,000 less than an equivalent new built truck. The chassis and cab would have the same warranty as a new showroom truck and you could get 300,000 mile warranties on the engine and tranny. Rears could be new and have their new warranty issued by the manufacturer. Spec'd right, it would get well into the 7's on mpg, be lighter to enable carrying more payload, and, more likely, easier to maintain. This type of truck would also qualify for no Federal Exise Tax on the purchase, whereas a new truck would require FET. Now we're really talking savings!
Just a thought. But if California in your plans, disregard. In my case, there is no reason to go to California. Gave up on California in '99 and no plans to ever return there with a truck. Rates aren't worth the hassle. -
You may be correct. But I am not going to base business decisions on questionable political trends. Even if such a thing was to come true, an individual could buy a truck I mentioned and, most likely, get full use of it before any mandate would take effect.fastrax809 and Heavyd Thank this. -
What kind of truck/motors are you looking at?
-
I'm looking at '06-'07 trucks and prefer a 9400, but since it's tough to find one around here with setback fuel tanks and I'm not a fan of the way IH sets up their chassis skirts, I'm leaning towards my second choice which is a 387 pete. I'm really on the fence about motors, I've always been a cummins fan but I just don't hear much good about the ISX. I have alot of drivers and mechanics tell me that even with the acert setup, the c15 is a better motor. Detroit is out because I don't like Freightliners. I thought now might be a good time to get a newer truck and stay away from the dpf crap for as long as I can without having to keep rebuilding an old truck, but with the problems I keep hearing people say they have with the post '04 engines, I'm starting to think I might be better off keeping the old stuff.
-
cheaper to keep her, you know the truck and have already spent plenty of good money on maint. good luck trying to outguess the state and feds. free advice and worth every penny
-
I agree with the last poster. I am in the same process. with over 1.3 mil miles, I have decided to have a inframe done for $6800 instead of buying a newer truck. I know all the quirks about my truck, & in the last 2 years put on all new air bag's, new fan clutch, reworked rear, other misc stuff. I know & trust my truck. with a newer one, I would just be going down the road wondering what may go out on it. for me.. more peace of mind with my ole one with new parts. & getting 6.0-6.5 m.p.g now. every one I talk to does not have a lot of great things to say about newer truck engine reliability. downtime is usually more costly to me than the actual repairs. good luck on your choice.
-
I too am in a similar spot I guess. Do I sink serious money in the truck I have now or upgrade for $15-20k, though not newer than '03. It's awfully tempting to stick with what you know.
The problem I have with it is if I do spend the money on the current truck, it won't be worth much more, certainly not what I put into it, when it comes time to sell. -
The economy has not bottomed out yet so I would overhaul if you can get three years out of. It might be longer than that before the economy settles and by then the rates may be so bad you might be ready to park it anyway.
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
Page 1 of 4