Peterbilt vs Freightliner?

Discussion in 'Trucks [ Eighteen Wheelers ]' started by ArmyVet88, Mar 14, 2017.

  1. ArmyVet88

    ArmyVet88 Bobtail Member

    11
    9
    Mar 14, 2017
    Maryland
    0
    Ok here goes. About to jump into owner operator territory. I have the option of a 15 peterbilt 579 13spd w/paccar mx rated at 455 w/271k on the odometer, or a 2018 freightliner dd15 10spd rated at 455. I've driven both, however freightliner I've driven the most, and am used to it's quarks and handling capabilities. My question is, which is worth it. The Peter is $200 less a month, but the fact that it has 271k on the dash scares me because I don't know how it has been treated. I know fundamentally the Peter is better overall quality as far as the build is concerned, but I don't want to sign for a truck that I might wind up going bankrupt on as soon as I try to leave the lot (due to crapped out transmission or notorious electrical issues). Any non biased, logical responses would be greatly appreciated. Oh, term length is 3 yes for the freightliner, 52 weeks for the Peter.
     
    Road Killer Thanks this.
  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. x1Heavy

    x1Heavy Road Train Member

    34,017
    42,130
    Mar 5, 2016
    White County, Arkansas
    0
    I don't think you will be allowed to destroy either truck. You may find yourself just stuck with the Peter.
     
    Road Killer Thanks this.
  4. ArmyVet88

    ArmyVet88 Bobtail Member

    11
    9
    Mar 14, 2017
    Maryland
    0
    Again, logical and helpful responses are appreciated. These are the options I have. Leave personal feelings at the door I'm looking for real advice please.
     
  5. tech10171968

    tech10171968 Medium Load Member

    627
    851
    Nov 16, 2009
    Daytona Beach, FL
    0
    271k sounds like average mileage for a 2.5 year-old tractor. But, if you're going for the Pete, I'd still get an oil analysis and a dyno test done before signing anything. Also, when you're kicking the tires, get one of those coolant test kits. Doing those three things will probably help you see any incoming issues headed in your direction from a country mile away.

    But the oil analysis is key in my opinion, because it will tell you the truth about that rig.
     
    Road Killer and ArmyVet88 Thank this.
  6. x1Heavy

    x1Heavy Road Train Member

    34,017
    42,130
    Mar 5, 2016
    White County, Arkansas
    0
    Go with the peter. 2000 less per month.

    Just don't abuse the Pete too much. You already know depending on your final drive ratio and what service it was in previouslyu what mileage it recieved. If you can get a APU in there, DO IT. And if you have quite a bit of working coapital built in, go with it.
     
    Road Killer Thanks this.
  7. x1Heavy

    x1Heavy Road Train Member

    34,017
    42,130
    Mar 5, 2016
    White County, Arkansas
    0
    Choosing a truck is a intensely personal issue as well. I defend it by allowing your very back and spine to choose which is better for you. The Pete or Freightliner. Ive done both. If I had to chose it will come down tot he type of seat installed in either one. Hopefully they will be the same. I lean to the pete because it does take a little more damage requiring less shop work to fix than does a freight liner.

    I have given you a finanical side between the two trucks once already as a push to get you moving. If you cannot already understand with your own two eyes the situation between then, then were finished here and my final advice is not to buy either until the economy takes off again whcih might not happen until a form of shooting war beteeen nation states.
     
    Road Killer and JimmyWells Thank this.
  8. ArmyVet88

    ArmyVet88 Bobtail Member

    11
    9
    Mar 14, 2017
    Maryland
    0
    It's $200 less a month, not 2000.
     
  9. ArmyVet88

    ArmyVet88 Bobtail Member

    11
    9
    Mar 14, 2017
    Maryland
    0
    Both trucks have a tripac APU. Financially speaking, I put 3k towards the truck, and have a little working capital, but not enough to cover a transmission replacement from day 1 if the tranny is crap in the pete. Personally speaking, both trucks are suitable. Yes, I love Peter more than others, because the ride quality is superior. However, I've heard horror stories about the paccar engine, whereas the dd15 is an established, somewhat reliable engine (at least for the mileage I can expect to rack up in 3 yrs solo). All the company freightliner I drove had dd15 engines with less than 455hp, however the engine was only worth a #### when paired to a 10spd. However, the 2012 cascadia I drove had Def failures out the wazoo after only 220k on the engine. My biggest hangup is, while the Pete might be the better option price wise, it's only so by 50 a week, and the fact that I only have 20mins to inspect it (without driving it) before I sign for it so I'd have no real idea of what I'm walking into. Tranny could be crap due to some Jackoff floating gears for 270k miles and not having any clue what he was doing, and I'd never know until it's too late. At least with the freightliner I'd know what condition it's in, because I'd be the first and only driver.
     
    Apedemak270 and Road Killer Thank this.
  10. ArmyVet88

    ArmyVet88 Bobtail Member

    11
    9
    Mar 14, 2017
    Maryland
    0
    I don't know how saying I won't be allowed to destroy either truck is giving financial advice. And yes, buying a truck is a personal choice, for many factors, however I'm asking for advice based on personal experience with either engine. I've never driven a paccar before, and I don't want to commit myself to a year long contract on something that might destroy me financially due to mechanical unreliability.
     
    Road Killer Thanks this.
  11. daf105paccar

    daf105paccar Road Train Member

    6,564
    7,293
    Apr 15, 2012
    0
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.