Hi there,
I wanted ask the fellow experienced car haulers out there about what they think about the screw actuated stinger car hauler trailers VS the regular cylinder car hauler stinger trailers. From what I heard is that the screw actuated is much more expensive yet much more safer and faster.
And then the minus part about is that they jam up? but the guy failed to explain how this may happen. Anyways, if you have experience with the screw actuated car hauler trailer,I'd like to know all of the pro's and cons about them compared to the other equipment.
Or if you can direct me to any site that has more information on this equipment, I'd highly appreciate it.
All the best,
Dan
screw actuated car haulers?
Discussion in 'Ask An Owner Operator' started by Jorik, Apr 29, 2008.
Page 1 of 2
-
-
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
-
I believe the only screw lifts you'll find are in enclosed car haulers. I have never seen one on an open sided trailer.
-
I'm pretty sure Boydstun makes a open screw trailer, They are big bucks and from what I hear the first generation screw trailers do tend to jam up. Something about raising them to far up and there wasn't a stop to prevent it is what I was told by a very experienced car hauler.
I'm not sure if the newer one's do that anymore.
I'll stick to my 9178. -
Actually you are right.
http://www.boydstun.com/products/index.php -
I just checked the Cottrell site, they also make a open screw trailer.
-
I did not know that. -
Boydstun and Cottrell both make open screw trailers. They have their pros and cons.
They weigh less than a cylinder trailer, so you can haul more. Some guys say they're faster, because the screws eliminate the need for pinning. The weight of the vehicle and the table can't overcome the mechanical advantage of the apex screw, so the screw won't turn and drop the table on its own. Wherever you leave it positioned, it will stay. There is less hydraulic hose and fittings overall, keeping weight down and creating fewer possible leaks and failures.
Most of the new models come with wheel straps instead of chains for securing. You can drop a table down to waist level and strap a car down, then run it up to the top if you like, eliminating the need to climb on the trailer, except for the headrack. This reduces injuries from slipping and falling, big companies like that. I've noticed some companies around here only strap the curb-side wheels, so a driver doesn't have to stand out in traffic. Several car manufacturers now require the 'soft-tie' straps, because it reduces transport damage. Toyota and Lexus are strictly 'soft-tie' now.
One other cool thing is they've eliminated the need to slip-plate. The screws and rollers are designed to be greased. All the parts are tucked away to the inside of the ironwork so the paint on the outside the truck and trailer doesn't get rubbed off, so that helps with overall appearance.
The cons are definitely cost, I think it adds about $50k to the price of a truck. They don't have stacking tables like the Boydstun 9178, so you're limited to 9 cars. You don't have the chains to pull cars down to height either. The screw motors turn really slow, so the decks don't move as fast. -
07 Toyotas still have chain hook holes, and I thought I hauled a couple 08s that did too. But I could have been wrong.... wouldn't be the first time.
-
I think they still have the chain holes, they just don't want them chained. I don't know how they secure them on the boats or the trains. I can't imagine they're gonna force those industries to switch to straps, but maybe?
I've heard stories of guys chaining cars and trucks down, and then moving the tables without paying attention and bending the frame, whoopsie. -
Even in the uni-bodies the chain holes will rip out before that happens. Or the chain hook straightens out.
Thats been my experience. I've seen a F 150 chained in the frame that some one had pulled the hole far larger than it was OEM, ripping thru the frame metal. (I didn't do it, I hauled it after some one else had done that)
Over a 1.5" tear in the chain hole and its considered frame damage. Or thats the case in the area I run and the auctions I haul for.
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
Page 1 of 2