Steep Downhill and you need to downshift

Discussion in 'Experienced Truckers' Advice' started by Lepton1, Apr 20, 2013.

  1. VisionLogistics

    VisionLogistics Road Train Member

    1,551
    978
    Dec 8, 2011
    Jellystone
    0
    Agreed. Good analysis.
     
    Hammer166 Thanks this.
  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. Upright

    Upright Medium Load Member

    643
    461
    Jul 13, 2012
    California's Best City
    0
    Man this post, really I wanna tell you how it is but seems like you being experienced you should have had the trainee on a a lower gear way before you pressed the panic button. Im saying all the grades ive been down, it tells you before hand that it is a downgrade. experience tells you that you should slow it down before proceeding. ive seen to many rigs at the bottom of the grapevine pulled over cuz da brakes were on fire. all you can do is laugh about it. effin rookie is what im thinking. go boy, get those few extra minutes flying by me. hahhahahahjajajajjajajaja. dam, hahhahhahhhahahhahaha, wow its still funny, hahahhahahahhahah
     
  4. Upright

    Upright Medium Load Member

    643
    461
    Jul 13, 2012
    California's Best City
    0
    I can creep down the grapevine loaded at 9th gear, not touch brake pedal once. just takes knowledge is all. but if you have no skilled trainer to show you then have a 9/16 wrench on your person to adjust the brakes at the bottom of the hill. I seen one rig smoking out at the bottom and he tried to make it look no problems by pulling over. funny thing was dude was smoking and fire dept was only way to stop smoking
     
    VisionLogistics Thanks this.
  5. hellpatrol

    hellpatrol Light Load Member

    221
    172
    Apr 22, 2013
    0
    I learned about hills in a old Mack dump truck with twin sticks and a defunct( read: non-working) exhaust brake . I would face this medium grade hill with a full load several times a day and although it wasn't too steep, it was long, with a climbing turn at the end. If you missed the turn you visited the gorge and trees on the other side of the guard rail. I would ENSURE that I was in the lowest gear( the exact one escapes me) before I started down because I didn't have a Jake brake to help, throwing around twin sticks while loaded and accelerating downhill was NOT an option and the brakes wouldn't cut it on their own. Prior planning prevents piss-poor performance. I makes me really appreciated the new 13 speeds with a flick of the thumb or fingers I can do what use to be a lot of swearing, clutch pumping, arm-flailing,steering with the knee-so-you-don't-blow-by-the-stopped-school bus with the twin sticks. AHHH the good-ol'-days!!
     
  6. Lepton1

    Lepton1 Road Train Member

    12,647
    25,588
    Nov 23, 2012
    Yukon, OK
    0
    Early last week I was sitting in the passenger seat going eastbound over Donner Pass. I think I've pinpointed the scene of the accident. Donner has a series of downgrades, often preceded by long stretches of flat or even rises. This particular spot is preceded by a long straight and flat section with a small hill to climb before starting the downgrade through a series of curves.

    I'd have to find more information, but another trucker told me that in the investigation they found that the truck was out of gear. This would make sense. If the trainee had put it in top gear during that long straightaway, climbed the short rise, and then started down the curving grade in top gear.... then he would have been in a situation requiring a downshift if he had a heavy load. It would seem that he tried the downshift and didn't get the gear, then he was in trouble unless he used the service brakes or trailer brake to slow down enough to make a clean downshift.

    As far as "road rage" playing a part, that could also be a factor. Since Donner has a series of downhills interspersed with long sections of flattish terrain, truckers that maintain the suggested 50 mph speed will often be passed by truckers that may be more familiar with the road or simply wanting to go much faster than the recommended speed. The trainee may have been trying to pass a truck that was "holding him back" and decided to use the downgrade as an opportunity to blow by the trucker that had the dash cam. My rule of ten thumbs is to keep distance to the truck in front and don't try passing on a downgrade unless there is plenty of room without other traffic and on a straightaway.

    I like your idea to use the trailer brake to keep the slow speed during your downshift. I've boldfaced your point in regards to turning off the jake brake during the shift. This is important to make sure you don't stall the engine, especially if you are upshifting from a high rpm.
     
  7. Boardhauler

    Boardhauler Road Train Member

    1,715
    3,501
    Dec 21, 2008
    Ballin' in it for Shakey
    0
    1. The accident happened westbound, I believe a few miles east of Colfax.

    2. When upshifting on a steep hill using the jake is very beneficial. If you are downshifting you will have the throttle covered & the jake won't come on anyway. I will sometimes heel & toe the brake & throttle so I can depress the clutch enough to get the transmission out of gear easily with my other foot. On a 379 it's really easy to cover the clutch pedal enough to shut the jake off without lifting your foot off the floor, I will do that to modulate the jake on a hill or shut it off to make a shift.

    3. Nobody has talked about this guys speed. He had to be going way too fast, like 65-70. At that speed no driving technique is going to save you.
     
  8. Lepton1

    Lepton1 Road Train Member

    12,647
    25,588
    Nov 23, 2012
    Yukon, OK
    0
    I realize the accident was westbound, my comment regarding going eastbound early this week was simply to note that I was trying to pinpoint the location and then look at the grade, curves, and condition of the road in advance of the accident to try and paint possible scenarios.

    I also agree that using a jake during upshifting when pulling a grade is a good thing as it lowers the rpm's quicker to get the next higher gear. I've come close to stalling the engine when in high rpm on a downgrade and trying to upshift with the jake active, best to turn off the jake for the upshift then turn it back on.

    I agree that guy had to be going well over 65 mph. That was his first big mistake. Then he yanked the wheel to the left to try and stay in the left lane (NEVER yank the wheel in a turn) and started to wag the trailer and THEN he yanked the wheel again as he applied the brakes (and we all know you never apply the brakes in a turn)... seems like by rules of three he made three critical errors. Notice how his tires exploded when it started going onto the right side wheels and then the rims started gouging ruts in the road as it went over? Bad deal all around.
     
  9. speedracer 1963

    speedracer 1963 Medium Load Member

    502
    308
    Jan 12, 2008
    illinois
    0
    top heavy load in trailer You can tell when the driver tries to change lanes and the trailer immediately tips to the right while lifting the left wheels up. not to mention he was hauling ### down hill didn't help any.
     
  10. hellpatrol

    hellpatrol Light Load Member

    221
    172
    Apr 22, 2013
    0
    With the newer engines the Jake shuts off if the rpm's get too low or your shifting. it doesn't engage again for a couple seconds after you have shifted. When I first encountered a Jake brake my trainer forgot to tell me to shut the Jake off when we were slowing for a stop sign and there I was trying to steer a loaded Mack with the engine shut down from the Jake . Armstrong steering. luckily we were only going a few miles and hour so we just stopped, cranked the Cat back up and started over again, lesson learned.
     
  11. CenutryClass

    CenutryClass Road Train Member

    1,539
    859
    Feb 15, 2006
    0
    its right after exit 139w, that 2 mile stretch is the narrowest and has the sharpest 2 or 3 curves on the entire pass.
     
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.