I have two contingent job offers currently. One for Dollar General in Walton KY, delivering to (you guessed it) Dollar Generals. They told me it’s a home daily position, as the Walton terminal only operates in a small vicinity. There is a *rare* chance for overnights based on factors that could be out of your control. But the pay is 94,000 a year (0.70 per mile) Monday - Friday, full 48 hours at home on weekends. It’s about an hour commute for me, to get to the yard from my house in Lexington KY. You have to unload it yourself with a lift gate, but I did beer deliver for months, so that’s not too bad.
The other job offer I have is hauling scrap metal from Toyota Manufacturing in Georgetown KY from a Roll off Trailer (or straight truck) within a 75 mile radius. It’s paid weekly and it’s $24.50 an hour. It’s Monday - Friday, but you have to work one weekend a month, potentially two weekends if it’s busy. Benefits there don’t start for 60 days, and I don’t get vacation till a year in.
The only upside it has over Dollar General is it’s only about 25-30 minutes from my house.
But really I just want more veteran peoples opinion on it, so I’m asking here.
Two Job Offers, wanting veteran’s opinions on which to go with
Discussion in 'Questions From New Drivers' started by AppalachianDruid, Jun 13, 2025 at 7:30 PM.
Page 1 of 4
-
-
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
-
One might be more money, but your unloading a trailer by hand?
The scrap would be easier. -
An hour commute for a home daily gig is a long way to go.
Imagine you are up at 2:30am (just picking a time), out the door at 3am, get to work at 4am. Now put in 12 or so hours, then drive home in 4 pm traffic for an hour? Probably more than that at that time of day.
You may be home daily, but you won't have any quality time while you're there, you're just gonna be passing yourself at the door.Flat Earth Trucker, Arctic_fox, wis bang and 10 others Thank this. -
2 hour round trip daily commute will be brutal. DG deliveries are legendary. I'd lean toward the Toyota roll-off, but I usually select based on hassle-factor not pay. Which carrier has a better SAFER score?
SAFER Web - Company SnapshotFlat Earth Trucker, Arctic_fox, Tb0n3 and 5 others Thank this. -
I’ve heard absolute horror stories from Dollar General accounts and drivers. Stuff so bad I wouldn’t ever consider those jobs. Heavy product falling on you; terrible store managers making your life worse; the company not treating you well, etc. That it’s a decent commute doesn’t make it appealing either.
I’d take the roll-off job. Sounds EZ-PZ, a good gig. Especially if there’s OTFlat Earth Trucker, Arctic_fox, hope not dumb twucker and 6 others Thank this. -
Flat Earth Trucker, hope not dumb twucker and nextgentrucker Thank this.
-
I did an hour commute with 12 hour shifts home daily for almost 11 years.
At the time I was broke as hell and it actually made sense, so I volunteered for it because it was a 4on3off schedule and saved me 120 miles a week in fuel versus going in five days a week.
It was rough, but I got used to it, and having a three day weekend was awesome, but I was worthless during my hometime Monday-Thursday. I found another job several years ago that I'm still at, with the same 4on3off schedule, but it's only a 20 minute drive one way, and if I come in on a Friday and Saturday it's 20 hours of overtime right off the start. I get at least 40 hours a month.
Working 5 days a week with an hour commute hand unloading Dollar General is going to be tough. Not to mention backing in their parking lots. If I had your choices I'd go with the closer commute and make up the money with overtime.PacoTaco, hope not dumb twucker, Sirscrapntruckalot and 1 other person Thank this. -
For the math to math on the DG job you’d have to run 520 miles 5 days a week for 52 weeks.
Arctic_fox and hope not dumb twucker Thank this. -
Tb0n3 Thanks this.
-
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
Page 1 of 4