Brokers and weight discrepancies

Discussion in 'Ask An Owner Operator' started by Miss J, Mar 18, 2022.

  1. Miss J

    Miss J Bobtail Member

    16
    21
    Jan 15, 2022
    0
    Hey all, How do you typically handle a situation where the weight information on the rate confirmation is drastically different from the Bill of Lading and or, the weight is completely off the BOL?

    I have two back to back situations...

    Called on a load that was posted several times for 43,500 lbs. I asked broker if that was the actual weight since there were several postings to different cities. I said, I have a 48 ft with a lift gate and my max is 40,000. (To give me a bit of wiggle room) Broker said all loads are under 40,000. Booked it, Rate con said 40,000lbs BOL said 39,500. Got hit at a weigh station for 600 over gross. They loaded us 43,500lbs. We had to have another truck come and grab two pallets. Now they are trying to hit us for the charges for the second truck. I'm having them pull call with broker and I have time stamped weight tickets. Not sure how the claim will be settled yet or what my options are...

    Second situation, one day later... Load is posted at 38,500, for 53ft reefer or van. I call, verify weight and that we can use our reefer. Rate con says 48ft or 53 ft van or trailer, 40,000lbs. We go to shipper and BOL says 44,814. I call broker and he gets defensive and asks if we can take standard weight of 45,000. I say it was posted at 38,500. A thousand pounds is one thing for variance, 6,315 lbs is another. I'm new, I look up standard weights for reefer and the internet says 42,500-44,000 depending on your tractor. I have a large double bunk sleeper, so I have always searched for loads posted at 42,500 to be safe. Is the broker in error for expecting a reefer to pick up 45,000 lbs as a standard????

    What are my options in this situation? Obviously, I'm not taking the full load, but I'm curious how y'all handle this.
     
  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. ZVar

    ZVar Road Train Member

    10,911
    23,832
    Sep 10, 2010
    Flint, MI
    0
    This will get more hits in the Owner section, you might want to ask a mod to move it....

    That said, it sounds like the first is 100% on you. After all CAT scales exist...
    Second one I would say is on the broker to make right. Obviously brokers lie, but once it's in writing they need to follow the contract. Back in the 3 months I did reefer 45,000 was a standard load, and 40,000 was an unheard of light load.
     
  4. MacLean

    MacLean Road Train Member

    1,364
    4,031
    Sep 12, 2017
    0
    You need gauges on your bags on the truck & trailer. Once you are loaded to your max you make them quit loading.
     
  5. REO6205

    REO6205 Road Train Member

    13,168
    60,495
    Feb 15, 2014
    California.
    0
  6. pavrom

    pavrom Road Train Member

    3,196
    7,327
    Apr 29, 2012
    NE illinois
    0
    I got surprise today , rate con says 43.5 - got loaded with 12.8 only
     
  7. Midwest Trucker

    Midwest Trucker Road Train Member

    5,912
    21,382
    Aug 31, 2018
    0
    It’s not all that expensive to have scales installed on your trailer. Normal dry weight limit is 45,000 and reefer 43,000.

    $1,000 investment or if you can do yourself pays for itself very quickly in time, headache, fuel, and scaling costs at truck stops.
     
  8. Judge

    Judge Road Train Member

    13,547
    90,025
    Mar 19, 2014
    Arkansas
    0
    Yep, get scales, there will be a lil difference, not much.
    I just weighed out at customer.
    A49D0927-B456-4228-97F1-7F906A89E739.jpeg
    Here is my scale on truck/Bluetooth to phone.
    11DF9CF2-AF3F-4C4F-92A0-107BBE1D50BE.png
    Only 40 pounds difference.
     
    Chieftains and Midwest Trucker Thank this.
  9. rollin coal

    rollin coal Road Train Member

    13,473
    27,499
    Mar 29, 2008
    TN
    0
    Put some air scales on your truck. Make them cut the load at the shipper when your scales show it's overweight. If they tell you to drive to the nearest CAT scale that's 20 miles away to scale it then bring back a ticket tell them to just cut the entire load off of your truck and to have a good day. Do not sign the BOL. Make them unload it. Probably burning a bridge with that broker but they're a dime a dozen anyways so no real loss. Liars deserve what they get and in today's market the shipper might actually be amenable to cutting the load for you. You'll have to be prepared for a broker trying to short pay you probably. But it's only a load and who wants to work with LIARS and CHEATS?
     
  10. RefMata

    RefMata Light Load Member

    100
    225
    Dec 17, 2014
    Nogales, AZ
    0
    You don't know what your empty weight is? If I were you, I would go scale the truck and trailer as soon as you have a chance when empty, that way you know what's the limit on how much you can load. Write down how much fuel you have on your truck on the scale ticket and keep it stashed somewhere in the truck so you know if you can load 40K, 43K, or even 45K with full or half full tanks. Every truck and trailer is different. I have a '99 FLD120 double bunk, several tools in it, pulling a 2008 53' utility reefer and empty weight is about 34500 with about 3/4 fuel (2 140gal tanks). So legally, I could load up to 45K, but I try not to grab loads close to that number because that means playing around with the tandems, and some warehouse employees don't have a clue how to load properly, so even with tandems all the way forward you could still end up 36K+ on drives.
     
    goga Thanks this.
  11. Jacoooooooo

    Jacoooooooo Heavy Load Member

    748
    1,054
    Oct 20, 2013
    0
    You should scale the load to be honest, getting busted at the weigh station for it is silly.

    We all get overloaded from time to time, the key is to handle it right there at the shipper. Most will tell you to go scale the load and come back with the scale ticket. Than they will rework to legal weight. You do that and negotiate with the broker how much he needs to pay for this extra trip. Other option is to ask them to unload, in most cases you want see any pay or TONU than.

    And yes, you need guages on your equipment especially since you have heavier than average setup.

    On the other note, there’s no “standard weight of 45k lb”. Standard is 80k lb gross. You don’t dispute the 45k number, you stand by 80k gross number by which I mean, when you get into situation like this you don’t emphasize what was your max to load, you just say that it’s loaded over gross and it needs to be made legal.
     
    ProfessionalNoticer Thanks this.
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.