Good question, really hard to answer. Have been down both roads, I rebuilt a 99 cornbinder. Drove it 1.8 million. Finally spun a bearing.
I sold the 99, the new owner put a used engine in it and it is still running strong. N-14.
So, bought a 2019 cornbinder cummins 605, HX. So far, has been a good decision. Had a cpl. issues but nothing yet that would break the bank.
Bottom line? Is a personal decision. Guess it is similar to dribbling a basketball. Either way can be financially rewarding, much depends on experience, application, terrain and your pocket book and other factors.
Either way? take real good care of No.1...
Pre emission vs Emission engines
Page 7 of 8
buying new would be the next alternative but you need extra capitol to comfortably make payments, unless you want to be a slave to it running 3000 miles a week, and so you don’t go broke waiting for your free repairs to get done if you get a lemonLast edited: Apr 7, 2021
The only way is pre emission . Or brand new with warranty.
You do not want to own an emission engine that’s out of warranty .
Its just too expensive to repair , and they break down a lot because of all the sensors and using EGR on a diesel just doesn’t work without it clogging up all the time .
Kind of like a German car.
you do not want to own a Benz or Audi or Porsche or BMW that’s not under warranty.
If you have the money a new one is fine .
The heavy haul company my nephew works for buys new W900s and replaces them the week before the warranty expires.
They learned their lesson about owning a emission truck past the warranty.
Plus the depreciation runs out about the same time the warranty expires, so they will have to start paying income tax on the profit the truck makes AND start paying the huge repair bills, so it makes sense for them to just sell them and buy another new W900
They usually don’t have any trouble selling a four year old 600HP 18 speed W9 with about 200k miles on it for $100k
they also have a large yard near a big city, with 24 hour security guard , and they rent secure storage space to other truckers and movie companies etc for their vehicles .John E. Thanks this.
So basically what you’re saying is they had some trucks, didn’t maintain the emission system, it cost them money to fix the trucks, so now they can not maintain the emission system and get rid of the truck before warranty is out. There’s nothing wrong with that business model. Lots of companies operate that way and that’s what makes used emission trucks a gamble for the second owner. All I’m saying is when properly maintained over the course of ownership an emission motor runs just fine out of warranty.Last edited: Apr 7, 2021
TallJoe Thanks this.
that said, I have a suggestion.
find yourself a good mechanic that is willing to work with you, then find a $8 to $10k truck and take the $50k you have and have the truck rebuilt from the ground up. Engine, trans and rear axles all reman, clean up the rest of the truck and put it on the road.KullenTrucking Thanks this.
Not at all what I’m saying .
they take very good care of the trucks.
Oil changed and other maintenance is done very well. Each truck and trailer gets a DOT inspection done , every WEEK.
The shipper they normally haul cargo for has their own satellite tracker installed on the trucks, to monitor the location and all
Engine data in real time and also requires on the BOL that the engine will not be turned off while their cargo is on the truck.
So it gets a forced regen , usually every night when they stop, or every morning before they pull out .
The last one they ran past the warranty wiped a cam , broke down while hauling a 11 foot wide load crossing 130,000 lbs
Took three weeks to repair , needing a new head and cam etc. about $20-25 k repair bill and three weeks lost revenue for that truck, and they get $10 a loaded mile for most of their hauls.
The tax depreciation runs out about the same time as the warranty. So the company is going to have to start paying income tax on the profit the truck makes, AND start paying for the repairs.
Those two combined make it a better deal
For the company to just get a brand new
Truck every four years when the warranty expires.
They have no trouble selling the trucks,
A four year old 600HP 18 speed W900L with about 250k on the clock for $85-95k with all Maint records sells pretty fast.
And I’m sure the democrats are looking forward to the day they can ban every vehicle with an internal combustion engine. that day is coming .Last edited: Apr 8, 2021
Page 7 of 8